Random Posts

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

Is Houdini a Positional Genius?

Looking through the book “Could You Be a Positional Genius” by Angus Dunnington, I thought it would be interesting to see how Houdini does on some of the tests because engines are supposed to be much better at tactical play than positional.  I chose some random positions and let Houdini ponder over them for a few minutes then compared results just do see how it would do.

The first position is from Liublinsky-Botvinnik, Moscow Championship, 1943.  Black has weak P’s on the Q-side and White is threatening to trade R’s, so the question is, how did Botvinnik meet both of those threats?
The solution is 1…Rd4! which is what both Botvinnik and Houdini played. (Fritz 1...Rd4 0.88).  The next position was a made up one with White to play.
The solution is 1.Rxc8+ Rxc8 2.g3! placing the B on the h3-c8 diagonal which is what Houdini suggested.  Very good so far! (Fritz 1.Rxc8+ 0.92)
The next position is from Lputina-Minasian, Protvino Zonal, 1993.  For the price of a P, White hit the dark squares and damaged Black’s Q-side.  What did he play?
1.c5! threatens to seriously undermine Black’s influence on the dark squares after Bxa6.  After 1…dxc5 (1…d5 2.Bxa6 bxa6 3.Qe2 Bc8 4.Ng1 and White prepares to evict Black’s only decent piece) 2.Bxa6 bxa6 3.Na4 and Black had to be careful.  If 3…c4? 4.Nc5 h6 5.Qc3 is good for White.  The game went 3…Be6 4.Nxc5 Bd5 with a good game for White. (Fritz 1.c5 0.08)
After 4 minutes Houdini suggested White was about 1/4 P ahead and recommended 1.c5 dxc5 2.Bxa6 bxa6 3.Na4.  Upon actually arriving at the position after 2…bxa6 and thinking another 10 minutes, Houdini was having some difficulty arriving at a definite conclusion as it had been considering moves like 3.Na4, 3.Kb1 and 3.dxc5.  Several times it changed its evaluation and preference and for a while even thought Black was slightly better.  Finally after 15 minutes its opinion was that 3.Na4 was best after all and favored White by about 1/4 P.
I also was curious what it thought about 1.c5 dxc5 2.Bxa6 bxa6 3.Na4 c4? So gave it 2 minutes to ponder that.  It agreed with the analysis that 4.Nc5 h6 5.Qc3 is good for White, and thought White was only about 1/4 P better in that case, too
And finally this position from Bykhovsky-Smirin, Beijing, 1991, Black to play:
In this fairly even position Black’s isolated P on e5 and White’s control of d5 suggests White stands a little better.  However, Smirin was able to exploit White’s somewhat weakened K-side and at the same time deny White use of the e4 square and create an outpost of his own on e5 with 1…e4!  After 6 minutes Houdini finally seems to have faltered in its evaluation
After about 10 minutes it was suggesting 1...Qf7 with an evaluation of -0.16.  Its second choice was 1…b6 evaluated at -0.10 and its third choice was the correct 1...e4 which it evaluated at -0.09.  At least it was correct in thinking the position was slightly in Black’s favor.
Just out of curiosity, I let Fritz and Fire 1.5 Xtreme take a gander at the position and Fire agreed with Houdini that 1…Qf7 was best and favored Black by about 1/4 P while Fritz 12 got it right when its suggestion was 1…e4 which it evaluated at 0.00!
Other engines:  Spike 1…Qf7 (0.06), Ivanhoe 1…Qf7 (-0.17), Critter 1…Qf7 (-0.19) and Komodo 1…Qf7 (-0.20).
I don’t know what one can make of all this but one point seems to be that even though the engines do quite well at selecting positional moves their evaluations, at least in this little experiment, tended to show they did not appreciate the positional nuances to the same extent that the GM’s did.  Houdini missed one of the positions and had some trouble making a decision in one position but all-in-all I think it qualifies as a positional genius.  The only real difference seems to be the degree of optimism shown by the various engines.
The fact that Fritz got the last solution right prompted me to go back and let Fritz 12 look at all the positions.  That’s why Fritz’ score has been attached to all of the puzzles, but without comment.  Guess what?  Fritz 12 is not the highest rated on engine rating lists and it has always come out second best when matched against Houdini in Blitz games but it got all four solutions right. That makes me wonder...exactly how good is Fritz 12 if you allow it to think for several minutes instead of making it play blitz all the time?!
When it comes to analyzing games, it really doesn’t matter much what engine we average players use so I have just wasted a couple of hours proving what we already knew, but it could have been worse…I could have been doing laundry or running the vacuum cleaner or watching television or any of a dozen other things that wouldn’t have been quite so enjoyable.

Monday, December 12, 2011

A Difficult Decision

The following game, played in an e-mail tournament, shows the difficulty one faces even when trying to evaluate a position with an engine. The database games showed a big advantage for White in the games played from the position after my 13.Qe2, but a closer examination of the games revealed Black losing when he weakened his position by advancing his Q-side P’s or when he played …e5 which opened up the position and White ended up with a strong K-side attack.

But what if Black doesn’t do either as my opponent did in this game? True, Black can’t undertake any kind of attack if he doesn’t do something, but at the same time his position is very solid and it’s difficult for White to initiate any kind of attack either.

The critical position seems to be at White’s 16th move where he must defend against mate with either 16.f3 or 16.f4. The first move was the most popular, being played 8 times in my database, while 16.f4 was played only once. Honestly, this is what influenced my choice, but as it turned out Black refused to loosen up his position and I couldn’t find any way to get my heavy pieces into the attack because they were blocked by the P on f3. So, it would seem that if White wants to play for a win he needs to play 16.f4 which leads to very dynamic positions that look to offer good chances for both sides. In any case if I played 16.f4 it didn't look like I was going to be able to crush Black with the ease the database statistics suggested.

At move 19 I could have declined the draw with 19.Bf4 but even though the engines say White is slightly better I was concerned that in the long term my hanging P’s would turn out to be a weakness. The most common plan would be to push the d-pawn in order to open things up for the bishops but in this game I felt I needed the addition of a N to help support that advance. But both N’s had been traded so it seemed to me that the hanging P’s might turn out to be a weakness. It just didn’t seem, to my rating challenged eye, that White’s position offered any real winning chances so I decided to be satisfied with a draw against my higher rated opponent. But of course, because I am rating challenged, I could be completely wrong.

Friday, December 9, 2011

Engine Analysis of Positions from Sao Paulo

Aside from the fact that this tournament featured “Grandmasters Under Glass”…they played in a soundproofed glass room…Ivanchuk and his wife being robbed at gun point as they entered a taxi on their way back to the airport and Nakamura’s stupid loss to Vallejo, there were a couple of interesting games that were fun to check out with engines.
About Nakamura’s loss: He was a P up when Vallejo completed his 40th move with 5 seconds left. Nakamura asked the arbiter, “Is that move 40?” Of course the arbiter was not allowed to inform Nakamura one way or the other, so he said nothing. Nakamura thought the arbiter made an involuntary body movement in the form of a nod that Nakamura interpreted as a yes. So what did he do? He got up and went over to the refreshment table and calmly poured himself a glass of orange juice while his last 45 seconds ran out and he was declared forfeited on time. Nakamura became extremely upset and appealed, but it was quickly rejected.
This first position is from Aronian-Anand after 17.Qb3.  Anand played 17…Rab8 and lost in 25 moves.  It was noted in Chess Life that computer analysis preferred returning the P immediately with 17…Rad8, but that Anand probably feared reaching an ending with a bad B and wrecked P’s after 17…Rad8 18.Qxb7 Nd4 19.Nxd4 Bxd4 20.b3  but he overlooked the tactical shot 20…Bxf2+ which would have given him the advantage.  I set this position up and let the engines have a crack at it and this time they did better.

All of them, with one exception, chose 17…Rad8 with an evaluation of around 0.20 for White.  Spike 1.4 preferred Anand’s move and evaluated it 0.39.

The second position is after Black’s 24th move between Nakamura and Anand and was very interesting so I was curious to see how some different engines evaluated the position as compared to the evaluations of the GM’s.

Thursday, December 8, 2011

Enjoy!

New York International 1948



Reuben Fine won the 1948 international tournament in New York. Although he had declined to participate in the world championship tournament earlier in the year and would retire from chess in a few years, in this tournament he showed he was still a very strong player.

The event took place at the Manhattan Chess Club from December 23rd, 1948 to January 2nd, 1949 and oddly enough, did not take days off for either Christmas or New Year's Day. The tournament was spontaneously organized by the Manhattan Chess Club when it was discovered that Fine, Gideon Stahlberg, Max Euwe, and Miguel Najdorf would all be in New York in December of 1948. They quickly organized the event and managed to raise $5800 in prize money.

Because of his schedule Stahlberg could not manage to play and Samuel Reshevsky was not interested in playing. Herman Pilnik found out about the tournament from Najdorf and notified the organizers that he would play if invited.

The players were given $250 for expenses and the prize money was: 1st place-$1000, 2nd place-$750, 3rd place-$500, and 4th place-$250.


Two of the favorites met in the first round when Fine defeated Euwe.  Euwe made a risky P-sacrifice in the early middlegame, but when Fine didn’t follow up correctly an even Q and double R ending ensued. Eventually, after the exchange on a pair of R’s, a Q&R ending was reached and Euwe mistakenly traded Q’s into a lost R ending.

First place was decided in round 7 when Fine defeated Najdorf. Najdorf played his variation of the Sicilian and the following position was reached. Najdorf took the c-Pawn evidently believing his R would control the c-file giving him a satisfactory game. As it turned out White traded his a1R for Black’s c8R then slid his other R over to the c-file and it was all over.
 

Thursday, December 1, 2011

Tahl, Positional Genius

When we think of Tahl, we usually think of sacrifices and slashing attacks, but you don’t get to be world champion without being a virtuoso in all areas of the game.  This game is all the more amazing because it was played early in his career at the age of 19.

At the age of eight Tal learned to play chess while watching his father, a doctor, and shortly thereafter he joined the Riga Palace of Young Pioneers chess club. His play was not exceptional at first but he studied under Alexander Koblents and by 1951 qualified for the Latvian Championship.  He had not played in enough international tournaments to qualify for the title of Grandmaster, but in 1957 FIDE decided to waive the normal requirements and award him the title because of his achievement in winning the Soviet Championship.
In this amazing game we don’t see any real tactics.  There’s the early thrust 14.h4 that made his opponent think a K-side attack was coming…after all, Tahl had castled Q-side so the K-side P-storm looks logical.

Then there was the “mini-tactic” at move 22 when he sacrificed a P to apparently weaken Black’s K.  But, only apparently.  The move was a diversion and Tahl immediately reverted to his real plan of advancing his K deep into enemy territory on the Q-side by way of the dark squares.  It’s amazing that in the process he even gave Black control of the e-file. It's fascinating to watch his King walk!

Wednesday, November 30, 2011

GM Anthony Miles

British GM Anthony Miles passed away 10 years ago this month at the age of 46. He suffered from diabetes and died in his sleep of heart failure in 2001.


Miles was a controversial figure. Once, in the last round of a tournament Miles needed a draw for first place and his opponent was also willing to draw to secure a top place so they agreed to a draw without playing any moves. The arbiter decided to give both players a loss; both players claimed prearranged draws were commonplace so there was really no reason to actually play a fake game. The incident started big brouhaha in the British chess journals.

Miles also had disagreements with chess authorities and with his fellow English players, particularly GM Raymond Keene and Nigel Short. Miles made accusations regarding payments that Keene had received from the BCF for acting as his second in the 1985 Interzonal and became rather obsessed with the affair, eventually suffering a mental breakdown because of it. He was arrested in 1987 because he was under the belief that he had to speak to Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher about the matter. He was subsequently hospitalized for two months.

In the November 2003, GM Nigel Short wrote in the Daily Telegraph, "Tony was insanely jealous of my success, and his inability to accept that he was no longer Britain's number one was an indication of, if not a trigger for, his descent into madness."

Miles was also noted for his acerbic wit and often attacked chess personalities in published articles. He attacked former World Champion Anatoly Karpov in an article entitled , “Has Karpov Lost His Marbles?” His review of NM Eric Shiller’s book Unorthodox Chess Openings consisted of just two words: "Utter crap".

In 1987-88 Miles spent a brief period in the US before moving to Germany, but he eventually returned home to Birmingham. He played in the 1988 US Championship and did rather poorly, winning only one game and finished 11th out of 12 with +1 -4 =6. I visited a couple rounds of that tournament and sat in on a couple of PM’s of Miles games and was rather surprised at how quiet he was, offering little in the way of comments as he played through the games with his opponents. OBITUARY

Monday, November 28, 2011

A Couple of Surprises

The other day I was poking around in the database of my games and stumbled on the game below.  The first surprise was when I noticed that I had actually returned to correspondence chess in 1999 after a long layoff…I thought it was 2004!  This game was played in 2004 in the finals of the CCLA open championship (started in 1999) where I finished in the top 10.  I don’t remember the exact place or who won it, but the strongest opponents I met were a couple of CC Masters; but none of the top rated CCLA players.  Most of them play in ICCF events.  My opponent in this game was rated around 2100 and the game was played using postcards.  The other surprise was that my opponent played the Beginners Opening which I have recently done a couple of posts on.  Since I lost a game against an ICCF Senior Master playing it and a 2100-rated player lost to me with it, it probably should not be played by anybody but beginners!


Sunday, November 27, 2011

Impressive Performance by HIARCS

Thanks (again) to Kirk who informs us that HIARCS found the winning plan in the Knaak-Geller position given below. Very impressive! For those that don’t know the 2nd World Chess Software Championship was held from November 24 to 26, 2011, at Tilburg University, in The Netherlands. One thing I noticed about this tournament was that everyone had to use the same hardware so that helped level the playing conditions.
The final standings:

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
P
1
4w½
2b1
bye
3w1
5b½
4b½
2w½
bye
3b½
5w1
5½
2
bye
1w0
3b1
5w½
4b½
bye
1b½
3w1
5b1
4w½
5
3
5w½
4b1
2w0
1b0
bye
5b1
4w½
2b0
1w½
bye
3½
4
1b½
3w0
5b0
bye
2w½
1w½
3b½
5w½
bye
2b½
3
5
3b½
bye
4w1
2b½
1w½
3w0
bye
4b½
2w0
1b0
3

I am not familiar with the HIARCS program but according to the Chessbase website it is famous for its human-like playing style and its ability to come up with the unexpected. Recent HIARCS versions are known for sharp attacking chess. More importantly they claim that HIARCS 12 has been enhanced through a new deeper search and evaluation of dynamic possibilities. They comment, “This new approach enables HIARCS to play interesting, distinctive aggressive chess while being sensitive to the needs of the position.” and its play has been improved in quiet positions because it is “more selective about the variations it explores to achieve a better understanding than previous versions leading to much stronger play.”

Actually, I’m not familiar with any of the engines in this event, BUT…the fact that HIARCS discovered 22.Bc2 and then followed it up with the correct plan of Bb3, Nf4 and Rbd1 really is quite impressive.