Random Posts

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Studying to Improve or Just Studying?


      Writing in the introduction to How to Reassess Your Chess Jeremy Silman comments how most instructional books really offer no instruction at all; most of them are a lot of positions that cater to a theme but never explain how to implement the examples into you own games. In writing about the classics, Alex Yermnolinsky admits that Tarrasch, Capablanca and Nimzovich were giants of chess but opines that he’s not sure any of them would do better against the Najdorf Sicilian than he did in some of his games.
      Yermo comments that just like with language, the ability to speak doesn’t have much to do with teaching others and that Capa and Nimzovich were chess ‘orators’ in a day when chess players were starving for knowledge.  Those guys had the ability (like all GM’s) to select and reject moves, as Yermo puts it, “nearly subconsciously on some higher level of understanding, which may very well be defined by…calculating ability multiplied by the pattern recognition power developed by years of training.”  The question is, how do you teach what you know to others? 
      In Yermo’s opinion they had no choice but to try a “scientific” approach by breaking things down into the elements of the positions. The problem starts, he says, when an average player wants to progress to the Expert or Master level.  Classical positional theory no longer helps and his advice is that when that happens, the time has come to “set those books aside and start working on your own.”
      Yermo points out that Alekhine wrote his My Best Games 1908-1923 when he was seeking backers for a match with Capablanca and so wrote a book extolling his genius and selected games (or in some cases, made them up) that would present himself in a favorable light.  Reading some of his notes you would think he had it all figured out right out of the opening up to the point his opponent resigned or that he played a long combination and saw everything.   A few years later Nimzovich was in the same situation of trying to get a match for the world championship so he penned My System. Many of the books written after WW2 just repeated each other. Then we got to today where the pendulum has swung from strategy to tactics and a plethora of How to Play the (insert opening) books.  Games by today’s top GM’s usually don’t have the clean cut positional themes like you see in the games of the old masters because today’s modern players are much more flexible in what they consider a playable position. This makes it even more difficult to explain what’s going on in a position because elementary rules are often broken.  Explaining those situations to his students was a problem Yermolinsky found difficult. 
      In HTRYT Silman says most average players don’t understand the true purpose of the opening, have no knowledge of planning and the thinking process, no understanding of elementary endings and how all three phases of the game are connected.  In fact, the first thing he did in the book was look at basic endings.  Only then does he take up his teaching on the middlegame.
      Silman also gives the hypothetical case of a player he called “John Everyman” and described how he memorized various mating patterns, forced himself to study a few boring endings and studied basic tactics.  After reaching a certain level Everyman’s play was described as, “He would try to attack, but his cowardly opponents would take a Pawn, trade off all the pieces, and eventually win the resultant endgame.”
      Silman’s hypothetical description sounds like Yermolinsky’s real student about whom he wrote that he had an “attacking style” and ended up with “the weirdest opening repertoire I have ever seen.  He would open 1.e4 with one idea in mind: to sac a P as soon as possible…as a result nearly every game of his saw the same scenario:  he would drop a P in the opening, then invest more material into sustaining his non-existent initiative, get a couple of fireworks out of it and soon resign.  It was painful to watch him struggle with positions I would find difficult to play.”  The poor guy was getting into positions where he had to find the only moves that would justify his sacrificial strategy. Space does not permit writing what Yermo and some other brutally honest GM’s have to say about modern opening books that recommend all kinds of offbeat openings and gambits.
      So when these guys who know something about chess and are brutally honest in presenting the hard facts about what it takes to improve speak, why do we insist on buying all the crappy books being offered that promise to make playing chess easy?  Maybe it’s the same reason we vote for the politician who’s going to fix the bridges & highways, strengthen our military, increase social security and make sure we all have good insurance, stamp out drugs flowing into the country, etc, etc and lower our taxes.  We know he’s lying, but something deep down inside of us causes us to hope that maybe, just maybe, he can pull it off. That’s all for today…I’m going to go study my book on the Grob Attack now.

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Incredible Draw!


The other day I was playing through a couple of games in Alexi Shirov’s Fire On Board and finally got around to playing over a game given without notes in the Foreword by GM Jonathan Speelman who expressed regret that Shirov did not include the game in the book.  I have to agree with Speelman that it’s unfortunate Shirov didn’t annotate it for us.  In fact I wasn’t able to find annotations anywhere.  It’s not possible for me to present it here with any notes because it’s way too complicated and I don’t trust engine analysis; the material is too imbalanced and I don’t think an engine evaluation could be trusted.  An amazing game.

Friday, June 22, 2012

Emil Kemeny

      Emil Kemeny (13 January 1860, Budapest – 1 May 1925, Budapest) was a Hungarian–American master, editor and publisher.  Chessmetrics ranks him number 17 in the world on their 1901 rating list with a highest rating ever achieved of 2638.
      Kemeny was born in Budapest and immigrated to the United States in the late 1800's and lived in various cities (New York, Philadelphia and Chicago).  He returned to Budapest in the early 1900's. While in the US he worked for the Pennsylvania Railroad in 1893 and at the same time edited and published the American Chess Weekly in Philadelphia and went on to edit a chess column in the Philadelphia Public Ledger and in the North American.
       During the mid-1890s, Kemeny was one of the strongest players in the US. He took 2nd at Skaneateles 1891, lost a match to James Hanham (4–5) at New York 1891, and won at Skaneateles 1892. He also won the 1892-93 Franklin Chess Club championship tournaments as well as the Championship of Philadelphia, the nation’s second strongest chess metropolis, with a score of 14–4, a full point over Walter Penn Shipley. The next Franklin and city championship, that of 1893-94, however, showed Kemeny crushing his opposition with a score of 23–1, a full three points ahead of Mordecai Morgan, and four and a half points ahead of Hermann G. Voigt. In 1896, he had challenged Jackson W. Showalter, the U.S. Champion, to a match, which Kemeny lost, with the final score of +4 –7 =4.
      He tied for 4-5th at Philadelphia 1898, shared 1st at Philadelphia 1899-1900, took 3rd at Philadelphia 1900-1901, and took 4th at St. Louis 1904 (the 7th American Chess Congress which was won by Marshall.
      Between January and July 1897, he published correspondence chess games in the Philadelphia Public Ledger. In 1903 Kemeny went to Monte Carlo to report the Monte Carlo tournament for the North American. He published at Philadelphia for one year a weekly entitled the American Chess Weekly. This paper contained a full account of the Monte Carlo Tournament of 1903.
      As strong a player as Kemeny was, he was best known for his annotations. The American Chess Magazine stated that "not since the withdrawal of Mr. Steinitz from the New York Tribune has the analysis of games been conducted in so complete and entertaining a style as Mr. Kemeny presents them."
      Although not a correspondence player himself he appreciated correspondence play and gave a great deal of attention to correspondence chess in the Ledger.
      Kemeny knew correspondence players studied positions in detail and in general conduct games at a higher level than otherwise would have been possible. In the Ledger for January 15, 1897 he wrote that "in correspondence play, where three days time is given to each move, high grade chess may be justly expected, but such flawless play in a complicated position, as exhibited by Mr. Ferris in the present contest, must be regarded as a rare occurrence."
      The Continental Correspondence Tournament began modern correspondence tournament play in the United States. Seventy players began the tournament, which was conducted first in sections in a Preliminary Round followed by a Final Round. Shipley wrote that the tournament included "many of the best-known players of this country," and "was the largest and strongest Correspondence Tournament ever inaugurated up to that date this side of the water."
      Kemeny kept up close watch on chess developments in Hungary, especially the first correspondence tournament to be held in Hungary and elaborated on his views on correspondence chess: "Chess by correspondence has of late become popular, and, though it requires considerable time to play a game, the result, as a rule, proves satisfactory to the contestants. Errors and oversights are minimized and in the majority of cases the game is won on its merits. Correspondence play especially benefits those who do not reside in the large cities and have, therefore, but few chances to meet opponents of equal strength. But the best feature of correspondence play is the quality of chess it produces. Ample time being given, the contestants are enabled to penetrate the position much deeper, and very often players of average strength conduct a correspondence game in a way that would do credit to a master."
      He returned to his native homeland in the first decade of the 20th century, where he died in 1925.

How To Defeat a Stronger Opponent

Greg Serper gives his advice on playing a stronger opponent in articles at Chessdotcom.

"Most chess players face this problem pretty frequently: what should I do against a much stronger opponent? And here when we say "a much stronger opponent" , we talk about somebody who is at least 300-400 rating points higher. Let's start from major mistakes in this situation."  Part 1    Part 2

Thursday, June 21, 2012

Alexandr Lazarevich Alpert


      Alexandr Lazarevich Alpert (born Moscow, January 1948 – died Moscow June 2009) graduated with a degree in physics and mathematics but mostly he worked as a teacher in a chess school.
      His whole life was devoted to chess and he was a pupil of the well-known coach and IM Abraham Khasin.  In his youth, Alpert had a reputation as a very strong player and took part in the championship final of the Central Chess Club of the USSR. Later he obtained a FIDE Master title. He played several times against eminent grandmasters in OTB chess and was fairly successful.
      Handicapped by weak eyesight since birth he also played tournaments of the USSR institute for the blind where he had a reputation of being one of the strongest players. As a member of the USSR team he won a gold medal at a one of the blind Olympiads.
      But it was correspondence chess where Alpert left his mark.  He obtained an ICCF International Master title in 2001, represented Russia in the ICCF Olympiad.  He also served in administrative capacities for Russian correspondence chess organizations and was the prime mover of the very first CC events played on the Internet including ICCF web-server and Russian web-server Chess Planet. He organized almost all friendly matches and and served as team captain of the Russian team.
      Taking in consideration Alpert’s great services for correspondence chess the ICCF Congress of 2009 awarded to him a title of an International Arbiter posthumously, and supported also the RCCA in organizing an International CC Open in memory of him.
      Alpert once wrote about CC as it’s played nowadays and here is his article in abridged format:

       In reality correspondence chess players use chess engines while playing CC games. This is an irrefutable fact! If a chess player wants to play against a human being, he should OTB or online on the Internet.
      The games of grandmasters against engines have no connections with our variety of chess. The fact is that Kasparov or Kramnik when playing against a computer keep the rules of OTB play while a correspondence player moves the pieces constantly. 
      In a game where "man + engine" are acting as a team the role of a man must not be forgotten. I am ready to play any such a player when they blindly play only moves his engine suggests. Moreover I am almost sure I will win.
      I'll agree his computer and engine are more powerful than me. In a game "man + engine" against "man + engine" HUMAN BEINGS compete each other.  In these games one must solve the task how to defeat a well-equipped opponent and this can be done using one's own intuition and with the help of an artificial assistant.
      A win is usually achieved applying many techniques and such a win is more valuable than a win on a blunder, on worthless trap or better knowledge of theoretical variations in an opening.
      I want to play interesting chess and to restrict the number of oversights. I do not like to automatically accept the engine's analysis. Analyzing a position with an engine is a complicated process that involves both man and machine.

     How do I analyze a position? First of all I want to know the 4-5 best moves with rough variations.
      Step 1. I have a look at a position with my own eyes and try to add my own thoughts to these moves. 
      Step 2. I examine moves suggested by an engine by playing moves on the board which the engine considers as best ones and watch closely the valuation of those positions.
      It sometimes happens that my position turns into bad one after I make several moves following the engine’s advice and that means I erred somewhere earlier. WHEN I find a good move it is too early to be happy because you then must seek where the opponent could have played better.
      If there is a refutation to my mover, I must accept it and look further.  However, sometimes right and the engine is not.
      Step 3. Psychology. Playing versus an inexperienced player it is sometimes possible to figure out what engine he is using and there is an opportunity to set traps. One should find variations (it is not too difficult to do) which are estimated as good by an engine but which are, in fact, not.
      Step 4. Endgame intuition. I have used it many times. In complicated endgames an engine often evaluates positions incorrectly. But when there are 6 pieces or less on the board, thanks to the Nalimov tablebases, perfect play is possible. The idea is to analyze an endgame as deeply as possible to reach one of these positions.  It is not important at all what intermediate valuation is given by an engine; one has to be focused on a final valuation taken from the Nalimov tablebases.
      What is the main idea of modern correspondence chess?
To answer the question above we should address the nature of chess. It is well known chess consists of four components:
• art,
• science,
• sports and
• game


      There are several varieties of chess as well. They are classical chess, amateur chess, rapid and blitz chess, correspondence chess and composition. Each component has a different weight in each variety of chess.
      Chess as an art shows itself in games played by very strong players in classical chess. Composition is a variety of chess art is seen most clearly. Sports play the main role in blitz and rapid chess. Amateur chess is just a game.
      Playing an online game I would never use a chess engine to assist me. Sports are sports. If the time is a decisive factor of a game it means we must obey it. When playing a game for fun one is expected to play fast and while playing a game with a standard time control one can think on a move for 30 minutes.
      In correspondence chess one can seek the best move as long as he wants and may use any kind of assistance in the process.
      Ethical norms for each variety of chess are relative.  Solving a problem with an engine kills the pleasure for the solver but an engine is an ideal tool when one wants to check out reasonableness of a problem.
      In correspondence chess there are sports, games and art but the main role belongs to science. One must go deep into position searching for the truth. It is too difficult to do it without computer assistance in any kind of modern science. If one is not interested in doing such a job he should leave it. One should avoid playing correspondence chess if he doesn't enjoy it.
       In fact the appearance of strong chess engines has raised a couple of questions. Indeed it has already caused damage to classical chess. The main problem for classical chess is losing the process of adjourning a game and analyzing it subsequently at home. Any game is played in a few hours nowadays. As a result the level of endgame skills has considerably decreased.
       A ban of using engines as assistants while a game is being played has resulted in anti-computer controls. But, on the other hand the progress of new technologies makes it more and more complicated. Engines are a direct threat to chess as a kind of sport.
      As a science, correspondence chess has no such problem at all!


Nightmare on LSS



      This interesting position recently came up in one of my cc games and I spent a lot of time trying to figure out (as White on the move) what I should play next.  
      My database had three games in it with this position with the results of +1 -0 =2 so that wasn’t much help.  The continuations were 23.Nxh7, 23.e5 and 23.Qg4.  Houdini suggested 23.e5 and my other “go to” engine, Fire 1.5 xTreme liked 23.Qg4. Still, I was fascinated by 23.Nxh7 and spent a great deal of time examining it especially because in my db of correspondence games by top-level players white had won. I reasoned that 1) white was a strong cc player and 2) he surely had carefully analyzed the position before playing 23.Nxh7 and 3) the engines evaluated the resulting positions at nearly 0.00.  So, not being able to find anything wrong with the move, I decided to go ahead and play it and the game continued 23.Nxh7 Kxh7 24.f6 g6 25.e5 Kg8 27.Bxg6 fxg6 28.f7+ Kg7 29.Bxd8 Rxd8 30.Qd2 Rf8 31.Rae1 reaching the following position which I realized was critical.


      In the game in my db Black continued 31…Bd4+ and eventually lost.  However, Houdini was suggesting 31…b4 as the best move and evaluating it at about 0.20 P’s in Black’s favor, so I decided to spend some time examining its suggestion. I ended up not liking what I was seeing; White always seemed to be slowly but surely drifting into slightly inferior positions!  Eventually after much analysis on my part we reached this position:
      Black has just played 54…Kxh5 and the engines are evaluating his position as about 3.5 P’s in Black’s favor but I realized that if I can keep checking the game will be drawn by the 50-move rule.  However Black discovered a plan where he boldly played his K over to the Q-side and captured my b-P arriving at the following position:
      Black has just played 75…Kxb2 so now I have to keep checking until move 125 and not allow his b-P to move.  Can it be done?  The answer is, “No.”  If you remove Black’s b-Pawn and setup the position in the Shredder Endgame Database, Black wins in 34 moves and if my math is correct, that puts us at move 122.  Still, all is not lost because if Black relies totally on engine moves to make his selection, it’s highly unlikely that any engine will recognize this and will possibly suggest less than optimal moves…or so I reasoned.  I ran several shootouts from this position and found some positions where black was threatening mate on the next move and white was compelled to capture the black B which would start the count all over again.  But…this situation always occurred slightly the other side of move 122.  Of course Black could probably find an improvement and save a couple of moves.  It was going to be very close!  Here’s the position after Black’s 88…Ke4:
      Shootouts were suggesting that Black was going to mate within the 50 move rule, but I’m still going to hang in there and play 89.Qe2+ and see what happens.  So what did happen? I know you’re dying to find out.
       I made a mouse slip on the server and played 89.Qd2 and resigned after 89…b2.  Disgust can’t describe my feelings.  How does one make such a stupid mistake on a server where you have to verify your move by answering the question “Do you really want to pay 89.Qe2+”  I don’t know, but this was a very painful post.

Wednesday, June 20, 2012

Stasch Mlotkowski


Stasch Mlotkowski (10 March 1881, Clifton Heights, New Jersey – 16 August 1943, Gloucester City, New Jersey) was born into a Polish family in the United States. According to the American Chess Bulletin, 1904, his parents were born in Poland and in 1890 the family moved to Camden, New Jersey.
       At the beginning of his career, he tied for 9-10th at Philadelphia 1900/01. He played several cable matches for Franklin Chess Club of Pennsylvania against Chicago CC in 1904 and Manhattan CC (1904, 1905, 1906, 1907, 1908, 1909, 1910, 1911, and 1912), as well as in a cable match USA vs. England in 1909.   He won at St. Louis 1904 (U.S. Open Chess Championship).
       He finished 9th at St. Louis 1904 (the 7th American Chess Congress, won by Frank Marshall, tied for 9-10th at Philadelphia 1904, took 2nd, behind C.S. Martinez, at Philadelphia 1911, participated in the American Chess Bulletin tournament in 1914/15, tied for 3rd-4th at Atlantic City 1920 (Marshall won), took 10th at Atlantic City 1921 (the 8th American Chess Congress, won by David Janowsky), shared 1st with Norman Whitaker at San Francisco 1923 (US Open), took 8th at Detroit 1924 (US Open, Carlos Torre won), tied for 3rd-5th at Kalamazoo 1927 and took 6th at Bradley Beach 1928 (won by Abraham Kupchik).
MÅ‚otkowski was an odd character who had a serious hearing defect.  He lived in a very messy room on Mickel Street in Camden, near the historic locale of the poet Walter Whitman. He was unpredictable and could never be depended on to show up for appointments.  His room was described as “messy’ with the bed always littered with  empty bottles of ketchup and the room full of beverage containers.
       Members of the chess club would give him a lot of items of clothing in an attempt to improve his appearance, but he had a habit of not matching anything.  He might show up, for example, wearing  a green jacket, brown pants and a purple tie.
       During his games he would chain smoke cigarettes and he would often get a nervous tick then get up and walk around, returning only when he had calmed down and was able to concentrate.
       MÅ‚otkowski was a strong player and did many of the annotations in P.W. Sergeant’s book, Morphy Gleanings.
       He was friends with the infamous Norman T. Whitaker and in San Francisco in 1923 he and Whitaker shared first place in the US Open.  At that time MÅ‚otkowski lived in California, and according to one acquaintance, he had tried to marry a minor movie star. Shortly after the tournament in San Francisco, MÅ‚otkowski had to appear in Federal Court in Los Angeles where he was compelled to identify the handwriting of Whitaker. The result was Whitaker being sent to prison (again), this time for transporting a stolen car. Whitaker never held a grudge though and they remained friends.

Tuesday, June 19, 2012

What Opening or Defense Should You Play?

      There is an interesting Webpage I recently came across on opening statistics. These statistics show the percentages of games won by white and black and the amount of games drawn from over 2 million games for 60 of the most common openings and 230 further variations of those openings. This page should give you a good idea of what openings and variations are the most successful for white and black. There is also a written summary below the table that summarizes all the best and worst variations in the table. As well as that there are lists of the top 10 best and worst openings for white and black and the most and least drawn openings.
      Of course results depend on a lot of factors, skill and knowledge being a couple of big ones, but if you just want to go by database statistics, take a look at the chart. Of course the results are probably skewed by the inclusion of games by low rated players, but that doesn’t matter because few of us will be meeting GM’s any time soon.

Monday, June 18, 2012

World Championship Fiasco

      To be honest I haven’t followed a world championship match since Fischer-Spassky. Oh, I followed the off the board politics of the K-K matches and the shenanigans of Toilet Gate, but all the other ones didn't interest me...especially those ridiculous knockout events.
      This last one didn’t interest me either...too short and decided by rapid/blitz games. Really?! Some posters on one forum complained the match was rigged. The comment I liked the best was the one by the fellow who said he felt like was watching a WWE/WWF wrestling match, where the script is pre-written. I don’t know if I’d go so far as to say the games/match was faked, but I like the comparison. Take the following gem.

Saturday, June 16, 2012

Classic Tarjan


I’ve posted about Tarjan before.  Here’s one of his typical slashing attacks I came across the other day.  Larry Gilden was another promising player of the day who also dropped out of chess.

How to use a database

This video by Majnu is very instructive.

Friday, June 15, 2012

Caissa's Web Game Viewer Test

This is just a test to see how I like this game viewer.

Thursday, June 7, 2012

Me vs. Nook Color Chess App

       If you are like me, the wife has denied me television remote privileges between the hours of 6pm and 10pm on most nights which means watching stuff like So You Think You Can Dance, America’s Got (no) Talent and a series of movies where women always seem to be killing their husbands on the LMN channel.  This is where the chess app on my Nook comes in handy.
      The Barnes and Noble Nook Color and the Tablet have a chess program pre-installed.  The program is limited to just a few difficulty levels (beginner, intermediate, and expert) and you can’t make moves for both sides.  Thus you are limited to just playing games against the program.  The time controls are none, 5, 10 and 15 minutes and can be set for one or both sides. Also, I’ve noticed that, at least at the 5 minute level, it frequently exceeds the time limit.
       Despite these limitations it does play a decent game and is handy for those idle moments when you have nothing better to do…like being compelled to watch stuff like I just described on tv, waiting in the dentist’s office to get your teeth cleaned or perhaps even while sitting on the john.
       Just for fun here’s a game I played against it.  In order to give me time to write down the moves, I set my time for 10 min. and the program for 5 min.  As you will see, it didn’t have much feel for the position and it made quite a few tactical mistakes when it got short of time but, all-in-all, it can challenge you.

Advanced Chess and a Tartajubow Rant


 Advanced Chess is a form of chess where the human players use an engine during the game.   It was first suggested by Kasparov as a way to increase the level of play. Kasparov’s idea was first tested in 1998 in Leon, Spain in a match against Topalov. Kasparov used Fritz 5 and Topalov used ChessBase 7.0 with both using engines Fritz, HIARCS and Junior. It was a 6-game match and they were allowed to consult the million game database only for the 3rd and 4th game.  The T/L was game 60 and the match ended in a 3-3 tie.



       After the match, Kasparov said:"My prediction seems to be true that in Advanced Chess it's all over once someone gets a won position. This experiment was exciting and helped spectators understand what's going on. It was quite enjoyable and will take a very big and prestigious place in the history of chess."
       World Champion Anand was considered the world's best Advanced Chess player, winning the three consecutive Advanced Chess tournaments in Leon in 1999, 2000 and 2001, before losing the title to Kramnik in 2002. After the loss Anand said: "I think in general people tend to overestimate the importance of the computer in the competitions. You can do a lot of things with the computer but you still have to play good chess. I more or less managed to do so except for this third game. In such a short match, against a very solid and hard to beat opponent, this turned out to be too much but I don’t really feel like that the computer alone can change the objective true to the position."  Of course, engine strength has improved greatly since then, but the point is still valid.
      There is a debate going raging on one of the forums about the legitimacy of players using an engine during the game.  Whenever this subject comes up, in the words of Bernie Mac, “It makes my butt itch.”
       During these debates, I always see comments like, it will be a match between computers, might as well let sprinters ride motorcycles, computers should only be used as tools, humans are restricted to shuffling pieces, it is disgusting and primitive, a computer does not give you reasons why it has played a move, computers ruin chess and the ubiquitous, you don’t learn anything that way.
       These people are missing the point.  It does not matter how disgusted they are with the use of engines in correspondence chess, which most of them don’t play anyway, because chess engines are here to stay and, like opening books, they are going to be used in correspondence play no matter what the rules say.  That’s why the official correspondence governing body, the ICCF, has no rules against their use. To use an engine in an organization that does not permit their use is cheating.
       This brings up another point…some of these people apparently do not understand the meaning of cheating.  By definition, cheating is a deliberate violation of the rules or other unethical behavior that is intended to give a person an unfair advantage.
       In OTB chess, cheating could be consultation with spectators or other players, computer use, rating manipulation, pre-arranged draws, etc.  In CC it would be anything that is against the organization’s rules, including consulting engines and tablebases.  If you are not violating the organization’s rules, you are not cheating…duh!
       As for the other arguments, Advanced Chess is nothing more than another variation of the game just like blitz, Fischer Random Chess or blindfold play.  In AC both players have agreed to use an engine to assist them.  My suggestion is that if you don’t like this kind of chess, then just ignore it.
       Ever since I can remember CC has not been considered real chess by OTB players. I remember a case years ago where a TD announced free entry for titled players and when a CC GM showed up asking for his free entry, he was denied because a CC title didn’t count.  In my own experience, I once had a game published in Chess Review magazine and annotated by John W. Collins.  Naturally, I was pretty proud of it but when I went to the chess club not one person had seen it and even my 10-12 correspondence opponents didn’t see it except for one and all he said was, “Saw your game.”  Hardly anybody pays attention to correspondence, blitz, blindfold, handicap, FRC or Advanced Chess games.  So, what’s the big deal if some people want to play AC or correspondence chess where engines are used?
       Another point is that in high level CC tournaments some players win almost all of their games and there is always some unfortunate soul who loses most of his games.  If engines were the only factor involved that would not be the case.  Engines make mistakes too else they would not beat each other. No, the difference is the human.  But, the guys who win those tournaments are GOOD.  If buying an engine was all it took to play at their level, I’d be blogging about my games in the World Correspondence Championship.
       The comment that really gives me a chuckle though is the one, “You don’t learn anything.”  What in the world makes these guys think that people who use engines are trying to learn anything?  One’s study is usually independent of tournament play be it correspondence, otb or Internet.  Certainly a person using an engine to win hundreds of blitz games on the Internet or trying to see how high of a rating he can get on a site that disallows engine use cannot be interested in learning anything.  He is motivated by other reasons, whatever they may be.
       Many players  seem to think playing hundreds of blitz games against dumbed down engines or blunderchecking with Fritz at 10 seconds a move is studying, but it’s not.  In pre-computer days, studying meant buying chess books and subscribing to magazines so you could receive instruction and play over games.  You kept notebooks and index cards on openings.  If you wanted to know about strategic or tactical themes you had to painstakingly search through games in your books to find examples. That's why the Informants were so popular. Nowadays you can do it in minutes on the computer.  But it’s the careful study of those games that yields results.  When it comes to playing over games on the computer there are different schools of thought on the benefits.  Some think it’s easier and more efficient.  GM Alex Yermolinksy disagreed stating he felt that physically moving pieces on a real board helped reinforce learning and visualization. 
       It seems these days though there are a lot of players who have never played in a tournament, know nothing about the history of chess players and approach chess as a video game played on a computer screen.  There is nothing wrong with that if they are having fun.  Likewise the same applies to any other form of chess you choose to play.  None of us are professional players and none of will ever, as old people used to say, ‘amount to a hill of beans.’  Not in the chess world anyway so play chess in whatever form you enjoy and let others do the same. 


Tuesday, June 5, 2012

Is Anand the Gretest Player Ever?


       Anand, the world`s best rapid player, just won the World Championship for the fifth time.  He first won the World Championship title in 2000 defeating Alexei Shirov then came wins in 2007, 2008, 2010 and now in 2012.
       In addition, Anand has six chess Oscars: 1997, 1998, 2003, 2004, 2007 and 2008  Oscars are awards won by poll votes from the global chess fraternity, including players and writers across the world.
       Anand`s early success came in 1983 at the age of 14 when he scored 9 out of 9 in the National Sub-Junior Championship and a year later became the youngest Indian to win the IM at the age of fifteen in 1984.  By 16, he was the National Champion and he won it twice more before moving on to fry bigger fish in international competition.
       Anand is known for playing at great speed earning him the nicknames of `Lightning Kid` and `Tiger from Madras.`  In 1987 he became the first Indian to win the World Junior Chess Championship and in 1988, at 18, he earned three GM norms within a span of less than 12 months, becoming India’s first GM in December.  After that his ascent was spectacular.
       His first big moment came at Reggio Emilia in 1991 where he finished ahead of Garry Kasparov and Anatoly Karpov.  That same year he lost on tie-breaks to Karpov in the quarter finals of those stupid FIDE Knockout World Chess Championships.    
       In Kasparov’s ill-fated Professional Chess Association he reached the final where he lost to Kasparov in New York City`s World Trade Center.  After eight draws, Anand won the ninth game but then disaster struck when Kasparov came back and won four of the next five games and went on to win the match 10.5-7.5. 
       In 2000 Kasparov and Kramnik didn’t participate in the world championships and Anand won in New Delhi and Tehran but nobody was really too impressed because most players consider classical match play to be the ‘real’ test. Still, Anand continued to dominate on the tournament circuit and won ‘Advanced Chess’ tournaments in Leon, Spain, 11 times.  His five successes at Wijk Aan Zee set a record.

       In 2007, he won Linares where the world`s top players participated…Kasparov had retired by then. However, the critics were still claiming Anand had not won a title in match play so he ended up playing the man who had dethroned Kasparov, Kramnik.
      This match was one in which, as previous world champion, Kramnik had been given the right to challenge to regain his title. By winning this match, Anand cemented the legitimacy of his World Championship status.
      Anand is the only player to have won the world title in three formats. In 2003 FIDE organized a rapid tournament in Cap d`Agde and called it as the World Rapid Chess Championship. Each player had 25 minutes at the start of the game, with an additional 10 seconds after each move. Anand won this event ahead of ten of the other top 12 players in the world. 
     Apart from his chess achievements Anand has been awarded the Arjuna award for Outstanding Indian Sportsman in Chess, the Padma Shri, National Citizens Award and Soviet Land Nehru Award, the inaugural Rajiv Gandhi Khel Ratna Award, India`s highest sporting honour. He was also nominated by All India Chess Federation (AICF) for the Bharat Ratna, the highest civilian award.
      Very impressive, but the greatest chess player of all time? Most players think the all time greats are either
Fischer, Kasparov, Morphy, Capablanca or Alekhine. Once in an interview Samuel Reshevsky commented that he didn't think Cap’s play fell of towards the end of his life, but that other players were playing at a much higher level than they did during Capa’s heyday so his results were not so good. Then there was Shirov writing about his meeting with Botvinnik and their discussion of the Botvinnik Variation. Shirov commented that the meeting was of no interest because the old man was stuck in the past insisting that certain moves were best when Shirov knew better.

     When Kramnik defeated Kasparov for the World Championship Bobby Fischer claimed in one of his radio rants that the games were fake…they were made up because nobody could play chess games that were that good. It would seem that advances in chess had passed old Bobby by, too.
      Anand is perhaps the greatest rapid chess players ever, but how does he compare to Kasparov? BTW…Kasparov is an arrogant, unpleasant twit while Anand seems to be a very pleasant guy, but when it comes to who’s the best, that doen't count.
      Each succeeding generation of players has built on the knowledge of their predecessors and as a result, they have advanced their understanding of chess to the point that surpassed that of the previous generation. So it is my opinion that Anand is greater than Fischer, Kasparov, Morphy, Capablanca or Alekhine. His games may not be as flashy as those guys, but as Reshevsky said of Capa, Anand’s competition is of a higher level than the greats of yesteryear.

Top of Form
Bottom of Form
Top of Form
Bottom of Form