Random Posts

Friday, August 17, 2012

From the 1949 US Open


Here’s a knock down drag out fight between a couple of masters from the 1949 US Open played in Omaha, Nebraska which was won by Albert Sandrin ahead of Anthony Santasiere and Larry Evans. Giles A. Koelsche withdrew after 6 rounds with a score of +3 -2 =1 while Schaffer withdrew after 9 rounds with a +4 -2 =3 result.  I have been unable to verify the spelling of the last name of “Schaffer” and it seems I remember having seen it spelled a couple different ways.  In any case he used to play in the early years in tournaments in Pennsylvania as well as Ohio.  In the mid-1960s when I lived in Toledo, Ohio, Dr. Joseph I. Schaffer was a very popular master associated with the University of Toledo.

Prominent Ohio Chess Players


      I recently searched Google for a list of past Ohio chess champions and couldn’t find one!  I was hoping to find something like they have in North Carolina and Missouri and probably other states that have a “Hall of Fame” list that includes brief biographies of past champions and prominent players.  Even the Ohio Chess Association does not have a list of past champions.  This Blog has a post on Saul Wachs  who was a very strong master in his day but almost all of the information I gathered on him came from non-chess sites!  I was interested in finding out some information on players like James Schroeder and discovered the following:  The Man Who Was Once Somebody and A Chronicle of James Schroeder.
      However a search of prominent Ohio players of the past like Jerry Fink, Lajos Szedlacksek, Tom Lajcik, Richard Kause, Tom Wozney, Ross Sprague, Dr. Joseph I. Schaeffer, Robert H. Burns and others didn’t turn up much.  Little or nothing seems to be available on these players and in many cases even their games are not available. That’s disappointing.

Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Sidney N. Bernstein


      Sidney Bernstein (13 July 1911, New York City – 30 January 1992, New York City) had two different phases to his career. After being a serious player in his youth he stopped playing for ten years and then came back with the idea of playing just for fun.
      Bernstein had an impressive record in US tournaments:
Tie for 2nd-4th in Marshall Chess Club Championship at New York 1930/31
Tie for 6-7th in New York State Chess Championship at Rome 1931
He played board two, behind Reuben Fine, on the victorious CCNY team in the 1931-32 Intercollegiate championships.
11th in the American Chess Federation Congress (U.S. Open) at Philadelphia 1936 Participanted in eight U.S. Chess Championship events (1936, 1938, 1940, 1951, 1954, 1957, 1959 and 1961).
Played three times in Ventnor City, sharing 1st in 1940,tied for 5-7 in 1941, and tied for 3rd-6th in 1942.
He tied for 1st with Reinfeld in Manhattan Chess Club Championship at New York 1942 and took 8th in Manhattan CC in 1955.   Over the course of his career Bernstein played Lasker, Capablanca, Alekhine, Rubinstein in simultaneous displays and scored many wins against Denker, Marshall, Mednis and Reshevsky in tournament play.
      His career was well chronicled in his book Combat: My 50 Years at the Chessboard, but unfortunately he did not write much else about chess. In the late 1930s he coedited with Fred Reinfeld a book on Kemeri 1937 and in 1947 the two collaborated on a revision of James Mason’s The Art of Chess.
      Combat: My 50 Years at the Chessboard is unusual in that he kept annotations to a minimum under the assumption his readers were not novices. However, in complicated positions he did supply detailed notes. Also rather odd was Bernstein’s omission of diagrams.  The reason? He thought they wasted space and encouraged readers to skim! Another oddity was hyphens between moves were omitted. It has long been a questions as to who wrote the book Reshevsky On Chess.  Reshevsky claimed he wrote it, but others suspected it was ghost written by Fred Reinfeld.  I once read somewhere that the fee was $100 which would be about $1500 in today’s currency.  BTW, Reinfeld also ghost wrote Frank Marshall’s My Fifty Years of Chess.

      In writing to Edward Winter, Bernstein related how he and Reinfeld eventually had a falling out when Bernstein was working for Reinfeld in the 1950s as an analyst. Reinfeld began complaining about Bernstein’s work.  Without telling her husband, Bernstein’s wife wrote Reinfeld a nasty letter and that ended their friendhip. Reinfeld was not a particularly pleasant man himself and he also had a falling out that ended his friendship with I.A. Horowitz.
      Bernstein, who had many opening innovations, wrote of the King's Indian …over many years I’ve come to feel that even the world’s greatest players (Karpov included) misplay the white side of the King’s Indian by an early e4. This blocks the fianchettoed bishop (as Black will certainly play …e5), allows a “hole” at d4 and forfeits the option of using the square e4 as a transfer spot (for example, my last move). I’ve always kept the e-pawn at home with the option of e3 if needed – and have scored numerous wins in that fashion. (Source: Edward Winter’s Chess Notes)
      Bernstein never contributed to the USCF’s Chess Life: “…mediocre bureaucrats” and “…those USCF morons” pretty much summed up his opinion.

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

A Chess Legend is Gone




The greatest Yugoslav player ever has passed away in Belgrade after suffering a stroke.

Another Failed Brilliancy


      I enjoy looking at some of my old games just to see how I played way back when.  This game was played in one of Chess Review’s Golden Knights Championships.  If memory serves my opponent was a college student from Kansas and was rated around 1900 while I was not long out of the US military and also attending school.  It was one of those games where you think you played really well and had some brilliant ideas and fondly remember it that way even if the game turned out to be, as this one was, a loss.
      Of course these days when we all have a grandmaster in our computer that will take a look at the game for us (most GM’s won’t bother unless you pay them) we usually discover the games weren’t really as good as we thought.  I know because Fritz has repeatedly pointed out that a lot of my “brilliancies” were more in the way of what could better be described as “blunders” and the games look like they were played by a patzer.  I know, that should not be surprising because they were played by a patzer but I once heard Dr. Eliot Hearst (I think it was) comment that the definition of a master is every player’s secret evaluation of his own ability.  Fritz pretty much destroyed that for most of us, too. 
      Still, the game wasn’t that bad. The opening was the Caro-Kann: Panov-Botvinnik Attack and for some reason I’ve always liked playing those type positions.
      The Panov–Botvinnik Attack is not surprisingly named after Vasily Panov and Mikhail Botvinnik and often leads to typical isolated QP positions where White gets rapid development, a grip on e5, and kingside attacking chances to compensate for the long-term structural weakness of the isolated d4 pawn.

Monday, August 13, 2012

Unfinished Chess Set/Making a Board


      OK, an unfinished set isn’t going to save you much money, but what you can do when you finish it yourself is make the finish any way you want it.  The Chess Store offers their unfinished 3.75”  German Knight Staunton set in white boxwood which is ideal for painting or staining for about $45. You can combine this with building your own chessboard using basic tools as shown in the 7-part Youtube video. Or you can also check out this link  for a step-by-step guide for making a board, checkers and a simple chess set.  I really didn’t care for the piece design, but if you’re really handy, it looks easy enough to modify the shape.  ChessUSA has a nice explanation of different types of wood that can be used for boards HERE. 
      I’d love to try this except I can’t get the wife to park her car outside so I can put about a million dollars worth of woodworking equipment in her half of the garage.

Playing Styles

In an interesting article the US Chess League attempted to classify different styles of players. Their list:


Technical: A technical player will usually play the same openings repeatedly and know them extremely well…they are hard to play against… almost all technical player's seem to have an incredible overall chess understanding. It's a very practical style of play…it's almost impossible to be a technical player, without being very strong, as it requires too much chess understanding for lower rated players to use successfully.
Positional Players: Postional players are more versatile in their opening choices and simply rely on their general chess understanding to find the right solution in all positions.
Attacking Players: Feel comfortable with the initiative. They want to be always attacking the opponent…some attackers don't even have to be great calculators, but instead just have a natural understanding of how to conduct an attack.
Calculators: Generally work very hard at the board. Even though their general chess intuition may not be the greatest, they make up for it by pure and raw calculation power. They try to always see one move further then their opponent, and are ready to pounce if you make just the slightest miscalculation.
Tricky Players: Repeatedly they will play moves that you didn't even consider and that just flat out look weird, to the extent that it may become very confusing for you… they are constantly looking for ways to trap and attack you.
Dynamic players: Usually pretty well rounded, but lean more towards the aggressive/tactical side. They often play enterprising openings and try to simply outplay you. They aren't scared to mix things up and are usually fighting constantly.
Practical: They understand that chess is a game, and the object is to do everything possible to win and not always to find the absolute best move. They usually will play openings they are very familiar with…these players often have serious holes in their theoretical knowledge. They just hope to get a reasonable position out of the opening without spending too much time…
Intuitive: A weird group of players. You get the sense that they simply understand where the pieces belong, whether the game is positional or tactical in nature. Their reliance on their intuition may sometimes be a weakness as they trust their instincts too much …
Logical: Try very hard to try to understand the position they are playing from a logical perspective. These players won't often try anything too unorthodox, however they also won't shy away from complications if they are necessary.
Young Players: Have not yet developed a sense of style. It's very rare that you will find a positional young player…
For a complete discussion visit their site.

PlasticBishop Closing

      The site’s owner, “Ste”, announced recently that the site will be closing in August 2013. That’s unfortunate because not only is another chess site is closing, but because a few years ago I had a brief e-mail exchange with Ste and he seemed like a really nice guy who was running the site all by himself simply for the love of it.
      I played a few games there but generally found the level of play too low for my liking (a couple of games only lasted 5 or 6 moves!). PlasticBishop was a great site for beginners and low rated players that was very nicely done.
      Back in 2006, Ste posted that it cost him £120 per month, plus advertising costs to keep new members coming, so all in all that is approaching £150 per month…all out of his own pocket. He stated then that his main concern was paying for the site's cost. In the process, he noted that advertisements don’t work particularly well on chess sites. As he pointed out, advertisements work best when you have a large volume of unique visitors on a site each day, but most sites have pretty much the same visitors every day. Once a person has seen an ad they will ignore it. That’s true, I do some advertising on my other chess blog and if I am lucky, I may make $10 every couple of months.
      When I tried visiting the site this morning the web page would not display, so perhaps they are already out of business. In any case, expenses, family life and other interests are taking their toll and as a result PlasticBishop is closing. That’s sad.

Friday, August 10, 2012

Total Replay CC Archive


      Total Replay has correspondence master games including miscellaneous games, world championships and individual tournaments; cosstables are included.  Unfortunately the site has not been kept up to date and only contains games from 1998-2003.
       I did find some interesting games.  Between 1979 and 1986 an ICCF CC master named Mordechai Rechtman whose rating at one time was near 2450 played six correspondence games against Samuel Reshevsky, scoring +1 -2 =3.
       Rechtman, born May 16, 1926 - Wuppertal, Germany, is a renowned bassoonist, conductor, arranger, teacher and educator. Together with his parents he left Germany in 1933 and went to Israel in 1934. Between 1946 and 1991 he was principal bassoonist with the Israel Philharmonic Orchestra. He founded the "Israel Woodwind Quintet" in 1963 and the Philharmonic Woodwind Ensemble in 1976. Since 1985 and for many years on, he was the musical director and conductor of the Israel Chamber Orchestra Wind Ensemble.
       While pursuing his career as a bassoonist Rechtman spent much time writing transcriptions and arrangements for wind quintet, wind instruments and large wind ensembles. His unique talent as an arranger has been highly acclaimed. He recorded 6 CD's at the age of 75, and in 2006 at the age of 80, came out with a DVD recording which demonstrated his unique system of playing the bassoon.
       Rechtman has been Professor at the Rubin Academy of Music of Tel-Aviv University from 1969 until 2002, and as Guest Professor has taught in music schools such as the Juilliard School in New-York, the New England Conservatory in Boston, Massachusetts, The Royal Academy of Music in London, and the Geneva Music Conservatory. During 1977 and 1978 he was Professor at the famous School of Music, Indiana University, Bloomington, USA.
      He was winner of the 2004 award of the Board of Trustees of the Minister of Education, Culture and Sports Prize of Music Performances for his special contribution to music in Israel. In August 1994, he was unanimously elected Honorary Membership of the IDRS.
       As near as I can tell, Mr. Rechtman is still around and still playing correspondence chess.  The ICCF rating list showed him active as late as last year with a rating of 2206.

Monday, August 6, 2012

Bobby Fischer Singing




From the Bobby Fischer radio interviews: Obscene language and babbling of a deranged madman, but interesting… LINK

Saturday, August 4, 2012

Download a Lot of Chess Stuff!


Chessdotcom has a lot of free stuff:

167 playing and engines
12 database programs
57 lesson/training
17 opening study tools
8 tournament management programs (Great for clubs that want to run a small tournament)
227 game databases
20 pgn utilities
23 screen savers
13 chess fonts
89 miscellaneous chess “stuff”

One thing I did like was the chessfonts for Fritz.  You can install 44 fonts.  Some will be to “weird” for everyday use but some are nice just to change about the display a bit. Here are two examples.
Celtic font
Chessmaster font

Thursday, August 2, 2012

Difficult Game


I recently finished another tough game on LSS.  What made this one so difficult was the fact that there were a few critical points in the ending.  But before that the most difficult decision was when I went for a position that involved a material imbalance.  As I have posted before, these positions are very difficult to evaluate because you have different engines telling you what the best move is plus the fact that engines sometimes put more emphasis on material than they should (for example, see the post below, Dilemma of the Engines).  This can make entering into those variations very dicey and, not being good enough to really know if the engines are feeding me good advice or not, I spent a lot of time analyzing my decision.  It turned out I was right…this time.

Thursday, July 26, 2012

Karlis Ozols


     Karlis Ozols (9 August 1912, Riga – 23 March 2001, Australia) was a Latvian-Australian master.
      Ozols represented Latvia on eighth board in the unofficial Olympiad at Munich 1936, where he won the individual bronze medal. He also played on fourth board in the 7th Olympiad at Stockholm 1937. In 1937 and 1939 he had poor results at Kemeri and Kemeri-Rigaand in 1942 he finished in the middle of the 1st Latvian SSR-ch. In 1944, he won the Riga championship.
      In spring 1945, he left Riga by sea just ahead of the advancing Soviet forces, landing in West Germany, and spent the next several years in various Displaced Persons camps across Germany. Ozols’ name vanished from chess periodicals until after the War, when he played in a few tournaments in Germany for displaced persons. Other participants in these events were Endzelins, ahead of Zemgalis, Bogoljubow and Hönlinger. In 1949 Ozols immigrated to Australia where he won the Victorian Championship nine times. He jointly won the Australian Championship in 1956 and became an International Master at Correspondence Chess in 1972. 
      Ozols was accused of taking part in war atrocities during WW2 but never prosecuted.  Many of the players who participated in the Kemeri 1937 tournament had charges of Nazi war crimes leveled against them. A 12-page report in The Australia/Israel Review Vol. 22 No. 14 (1-22 October 1997) states that Karlis Ozols “executed thousands of Jews and liquidated entire Latvian villages during World War II.” Among the specific claims were that on 1 July 1941 he joined the Latvian Security Police in Riga; that in early 1942 he was trained at Fürstenberg (Germany), an establishment run by the Sicherheitsdienst (the security service of Himmler’s SS); that he commanded a unit of about 100 Latvians which, between 24 July 1942 and 27 September 1943, assisted in the transportation, guarding and execution of Jews; that between July 1942 and September 1943 over 10,000 Jews from the Minsk ghetto were murdered, with Ozols personally carrying out some killings; that on 8-9 February 1943 Ozols and 110 Latvians under his command assisted the SS to kill more than 2,000 Jews of the Slutz ghetto. “The killings [open-air shootings and gas vans] were efficiently organized. Orders directly from Hitler were passed down the SS hierarchy to the Latvian officers under their command.” On 20 April 1944 Ozols was promoted to the rank of Obersturmführer and was decorated with the KVK II (Kriegsverdienstkreuz – the War Merit Cross). The following December, he disappeared.
      In Australia in June 1992 the Senior Counsel advised the Director of Public Prosecutions that a prima facie case existed against Ozols concerning war crimes and genocide. However, that same month the Federal Government shut down the Unit. The Director of Public Prosecutions wished to continue, but was stopped by the Attorney General. The case was closed. The result was Ozols was never prosecuted for war crimes.
      Ozols refused to talk about his war time activities and in a 1979 interview he stated that he had been in Riga when the Germans had arrived in 1941, that former officers of the Latvian reserve had been asked to offer their services and that he had merely carried out guard duties.
      In July 2002 a program was launched calling on Baltic citizens to identify suspected Nazi collaborators for monetary rewards. The result was the Latvian government investigated Ozols who was accused of collaboration with the Nazis while serving in the SS-affiliated Arajs Commando.  Of course Ozols had dies in 2001, rendering the investigation moot.
      In the October 1-22, 1997 issue of the Australia/Israel Review the article titled Our shame; His haven Australia's Nazi cover-up wrote:
      "Ozols is tall, thin, has a back like a ram rod and a peculiarly strident voice…of the masters who have come to Australia since World War II, Ozols has taken the biggest part in competitive play and has been the most successful. And for 37 years the deception had been very successful.”
      In 1986 Mark Aarons, a journalist with ABC radio, broadcast years of research. It was called "Nazis in Australia" and went to air on April 13 1986. The program raised dramatic allegations and evidence about Nazi war criminals who had been allowed to immigrate to Australia, many with the knowledge of Australian authorities.
      In another article for the same issue of the Australia/Israel Review, entitled Fingering the SS, which presented findings on Ozols the author wrote:
      “Karlis Ozols was not yet 30 when the Germans marched into Latvia in July 1941. A former law student at Riga University…Within a year, the then tall and slender young man was a member of a brutally efficient SS killing machine, the Arajs Kommando. Ozols' activities between July 1941, when the Nazis arrived in Latvia, and March 1942 when he can definitely be traced to a Nazi SD (Security Police) training school in Germany where he learned the fine points of mass murder, cannot be accounted for precisely…By some accounts Ozols was active in slaughtering Jews from the Riga ghetto in the Bikinieki forest, a site notorious in this period as the "role model" for the techniques adopted at similar mass exterminations throughout Central and Eastern Europe. Other accounts place him at the site of similar mass murders in and around Liepaja in the second half of 1941.”
      All the evidence linking Ozols to the Arajs Kommandos  was circumstantial, but on victim wrote in a signed statement: "I remember Karlis Ozols well.  He was company commander and his rank was initially lieutenant and then senior lieutenant. At that time Ozols was about 30 years old, rather tall, slim and slender. I personally served in the security police and SD company commanded by Ozols from the summer of 1942 to the autumn of 1943."
      Ozols stated that on one occasion towards the end of his term, he was ordered to guard the site of a mass execution, about twenty kilometers from Minsk. Ordered to stand guard about 200 meters from the grave and said that Karlis Ozols was at the site where the Jews were being shot.
      In another signed statement one Private Zuika said he remembered that Senior Lieutenant Ozols was among the persons who executed peaceful Soviet civilians. He was armed with a sub-machine gun. Usually during such actions, “Ozols was a little drunk, because he took alcoholic drinks before executions."
      In his brief to the , former Director of the National Crime Authority, Peter Faris presented all his damning evidence to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecution, recommending the prosecution of Ozols:
"....it is my view that the circumstances are so overwhelming and the period of time so long (14 months) that, putting aside evidence of direct killing by Ozols, a jury would find that, beyond reasonable doubt, he knew that his men were, upon his orders, either killing, assisting in the killing or guarding.

      "Further, the evidence is equally strong that he knew that this was all done in the pursuit of a policy of genocide. I believe that knowledge can be established beyond reasonable doubt, and that upon further investigation, the evidence will probably become stronger."
      For most of his life in Australia he lived quietly with his wife Erika in an outer suburb of Melbourne. During the 1990s he was a frequent visitor to a Latvian retirement village wherein resided his boyhood friend Konrad Kalejs (another alleged war criminal), who had been deported from Canada.
      Ozols, on his alleged involvement in Nazi war crimes said, “It is all finished. No one have I killed and I have never asked anyone to kill. I don't know anything. I have nothing to say." However, some years earlier when questioned by a local newspaper, he had acknowledged sympathy for the German occupation of Latvia while denying any collaboration with the Nazis in the extermination of Jews.
      Ozols died in Melbourne in March 2001 at age 88, spending the last years of his life institutionalized for dementia. Dementia is a serious loss of cognitive abilities in a previously unimpaired person, beyond what might be expected from normal aging. It may affect memory, attention, language and problem solving.


Monday, July 23, 2012

Dumbing Down Engines for Practice


      First, it’s extremely difficult to get an engine to play human-like chess because humans don’t crunch numbers and deal in absolutes. Humans use a lot of intuition. Sometimes if you ask a GM why he played a certain move he doesn’t know.  All he can say is it looked good.  Why did it look good?  He can’t say.  Intuition was involved. Engines don’t calculate that way. They recommend a move because they have calculated it to be the best in mathematical terms.

There are two general ways to dumb down an engine:
1) Limit the depth of the search. Changing how deep and how long the computer thinks changes its strength.  The problem with changing only the time an engine is allowed to think is that today’s engines can spot strong moves in an instant so even giving them 2 seconds to think means they will still play a pretty strong game.
2) Changing the evaluation criteria. Engines count material and evaluate positional characteristics in a certain way. Change these parameters and you will change its strength.


      Most often strong players make subtle positional mistakes while weaker players make serious tactical errors and gross blunders. As you drop down the rating list you find players making little mistakes that allow their opponent to accumulate small advantages with a few tactical errors thrown in and the further down you go, the more glaring these mistakes become. Hard to duplicate.
      Here is a dirty little programming secret.  In order to dumb down an engine many programs are disguised to give you material odds!  They either just make a stupid outright blunder and hang material or in some cases deliberately set up situations where you can execute a little combination to pick up your material. The problem often is that after the engine gives you your material advantage it starts playing like Anand.
      The result of all this is you can never get an engine to play like a human, especially at lower levels because it is extremely difficult to program to play like humans and not, well, machines.
      My suggestion for getting an engine to practice against at lower levels is twofold.  First, using your program, make an opening book from games played by players below whatever rating level you select.  Personally, I’d make the opening book maybe 15 moves deep.  Second, go to a place like Jib Alblett’s Winboard Project site (link listed on this Blog) and download one of the weaker engines. Then you can play against the weaker engine using actual opening moves of lower rated players and afterwards let your GM strength engine show you all the missed wins.  It’s not an ideal solution, but it’s the best I can think of.

Saturday, July 21, 2012

4-Shared Snafu


      On Sunday, July 15 I received an email from the file storage site 4Shareddotcom advising me that it was reported that I “offer unlicensed copies of, or been engaged in other unauthorized activities relating to copyrighted works. The abuse report came to us from LeakID. Storing and sharing of such material violates proprietary rights of the file copyright owner as well as 4shared Terms of Use”
      What was involved was my offering for download my 28 page pdf booklet on the Dallas 1957 chess tournament.  This is, of course not the case, because this booklet consists of a brief description of the tournament and some anno-Fritzed games. 
      I sent an e-mail back describing the material and received what appeared to be an automated reply signed by someone name “Josh” at 4Shared.  Basically the e-mailed advised me it wasn’t their problem and I should please “get in touch with the reporter via email (e-mail listed for Leak) and figure this out.”
      According to their website, LeakID “is the first digital agency and was founded by experts from the world of radio, television and internet. We undertake the design, management, strategy ...etc.”  According to LinkedIn they are Specialists in Law Enforcement IP, content protection, anti-piracy, Anti Counterfeiting.
     According to the customer service people, leakid is spamming Sendspace with takedown notices: "We keep being sent takedown notices by leakid.com. You will probably wish to take this up with them."  Interesting that even Sendspace, like 4Shared, doesn't seem to care that this is a problem for some of their site's users.  Obviously if LeakedID is doing spamming they won't be too concerned about complaints will they?
      As expected, I never heard from LeakID. Apparently I have not been the only person to have experienced problems with this issue involving both 4Sahred and LeakIt.  As a result I have deleted my 4Shared account and am no longer offering my pdf booklets for download unless I can find another site.

Wednesday, July 18, 2012

Dilemma of the Engines


In regards to the recent post concerning the dilemma of choosing from a variety of moves and evaluations, here is a good example of what kind of problems one can face when it comes to using engines.  In the following position what move would you choose as White?  All the suggested moves are likely good, but you want to choose the BEST.

Note: move recommendations are after about 5 minutes:
By move:

Deep Saros 14.a4 (0.00)
Critter 14.a4 (0.13)
Houdini 14.a4 (0.12)
Rybka 14.Qb1 (0.10)
Spike 14.Qb1 (0.30)
Stockfish 14.Qb1 (0.48)
Fritz 12 14.e5 (0.24)
Fire Xtreme 14.b4 (0.30)
Komodo 14.Rc1 (0.21)

By Evaluation:

Stockfish 14.Qb1 (0.48)
Spike 14.Qb1 (0.30)
Fire Xtreme 14.b4 (0.30)
Fritz 12 14.e5 (0.24)
Critter 14.a4 (0.13)
Houdini 14.a4 (0.12)
Rybka 14.Qb1 (0.10)
Deep Saros 14.a4 (0.00)

Andriy Sliusarchuk Defeats Rybka

April 28, 2011 WNU (Worldwide News Ukraine) ran the above headline stating Sliusarchuk beat the chess engine Rybka-4.
“It took neurosurgeon only 50 minutes to beat the machine. The computer gave up. Sliusarchuk won after two games with a score of 1.5:0.5. To ensure the experiment was fair, the professor, prior to the tournament, was checked for possible cheating or receiving any tips, reports TSN. Sliusarchuk taught himself to play chess only eight months before the tournament took place to beat “artificial intelligence”. The winner stated that he would like to create a Brain Institute to investigate unrecognized capabilities of human beings. Previously, the Ukrainian professor became famous for memorizing the record 30 million digits of “pi”. He also claims to have memorized 20 thousand books.”

      Slyusarchuk (born May 9, 1971 in the Ukraine) was as impostor who became, among other things, neurosurgeon, medical doctor and professor. He also claimed to have set a number of unverified world records in memorizing data and figures, while being able to perform highly complex computer-speed calculations mentally. He was commonly known as Doctor Pi.

      He was taken seriously in Ukraine where he even had a meeting with the President. One of the major TV channels in Ukraine even hosted a few TV events in which Slyusarchuk demonstrated many of his extraordinary abilities.
      Slyusarchuk claimed to be a chess amateur who read three thousand books about the game and then went on to beat Rybka blindfold. He also performed other mental feats like memorizing 80 chess boards in 4.5 minutes and then identifying changes made to them. Of course it was faked.



     Journalists of Lviv newspaper "Express", in a series of articles in October-November 2011, accused him of forgery, fraud, illegal medical practice, which led to injuries and deaths of patients treated by him.

     Of course he publicly denied them and pleaded not guilty in a number of interviews to other press sources. He announced that he had resorted to court and applied to General Prosecutor of Ukraine in order to clarify the situation and officially disprove the statements made by "Express".
    On November 14, 2011, under the pressure of press the Ukrainian police detained him for the period of investigation on suspicion of forgery and fraud. In the investigation officials officially announced to press that all the documents and scientific titles of Andriy Slyusarchuk are valid, according to the Ukrainian legislation and procedures. As per their statements, major parts of Slyusarchuk's scientific works would not be disclosed, as they are classified and fall under the category of State secrets privilege both in Ukraine and Russia.
     In Summer 2012 Ukrainian newspapers reported that Andriy Slyusarchuk left Lukyanivka jail and was placed in psychiatric hospital. The Head of Department for Public Affairs of MIA of Ukraine said that "independent examination were conducted to check the mental health of Slyusarchuk, as well as his possible psychic and hypnotic abilities"When he tried to fake the chess position memory on TV, his scam was revealed by experts. In the May 30, 2011 edition of the Boston Globe authors Harold Dondis and GM Patrick Wolff wrote, “We must conclude that the so-called Memory Man, who did not know how to castle or move a knight, is the latest in ingenious chess frauds.”

Tuesday, July 17, 2012

Bellyaching about Engines


        I saw it again.  On one of the forums there was a discussion about correspondence play, specifically playing for the ICCF which allows engine use.  It was mentioned by a couple of people that engine use was cheating and there was no point in playing engine assisted games because it would be very boring anyway.
        First of all if a site allows the use of engines for analysis it is not cheating any more than the use of opening books and databases is cheating on sites that say you can consult them.  I don’t understand the thought process that says even if something is within the organization’s guidelines and you do it, it’s still cheating.  I even heard one guy say that he considers using books in correspondence chess cheating. How can that be?!  Anyway, he probably cheats, too. When he plays correspondence chess, I bet he uses a lot more time than OTB players and I’d go even further and say he touches the pieces and moves them around which is cheating in over the board chess. Hey!  If it’s cheating in tournament chess, it’s got to be cheating in correspondence, right?  What they don’t realize is that OTB chess and correspondence chess are not the same thing. 
      Maybe they don’t want to use engines in their games, and that’s OK.  If that’s the way they feel then I have no problem with it and the solution for them is simple…don’t play on ICCF or any site that allows engine use…problem solved.
      I don’t like chess problems, but I know one guy who does; in fact he’s a Master Solver with the US problem solving organization.  If that’s what he likes to do then I don’t have a problem with it and I’d never tell him it’s a waste of time to mess around with positions that will never come up in real play.  They also have problems where pieces move in ways they don’t move in regular chess.  So what?  That’s what those guys enjoy. I don’t, so I don’t get involved, but neither do I belittle an aspect of the game they like.
      Some time back the ICCF had an interview with an OTB GM who was just getting into CC.  He said he did it because he was not interested only in the competitive nature of the game, but appreciated the search for hidden and deep ideas and thought he could be more creative in correspondence games without the tension found in OTB.
       I found it interesting that he mentioned a point I’ve made here is some posts…most engines do not understand positions with a material imbalance. He also commented that even with computers, one can never be lazy, adding that sometimes the search for the best move can take days and even then there is no guarantee you will find the proper answer.
       In his correspondence games he uses all engines available. The search for the best move, which is what he is trying to find, should, in his opinion, meet no boundaries. He pointed out that blindly following engine suggestions will usually lead to disaster and that in the end the best players will win anyway
       On ICCF where deep engine analysis drives most of your opponents' moves, it becomes paramount to be well-prepared in the opening. His procedure is to create a database of all ICCF games and then extract the first 40 moves into a new opening book. This gives him an opening overview which he can use to maximize his chances against the best engines. He also added that he has found several examples of top GMs building their opening lines based on ICCF games.
       He believes preparation is just as important (if not more so) than having an engine churning out moves. The main aspect is opening preparation. Without solid preparation, you can lose the game before your engine can save it.  Simply using the moves an engine comes up with is usually not enough to win; you have to use everything at your disposal, including human intuition.
       If a player is what is known if the CC world as a “postman” and just delivers what the engine says is the best move after a minute’s thought, then yes, it would be boring and there wouldn’t be much point in playing. But, how can a 1500 second guess an engine?  They probably can’t but what they can do is do a lot of research, compile opening books and databases of top level games that will allow them to get good positions for the engines to work on.
       Then using different engines they will often find there are different alternatives and different evaluations of the same position.  Also in some positions engines are fickle and will keep changing their mind on the evaluation. It is then up to the player to decide which move is best. What does a 1500 do in these situations?  He keeps on analyzing and researching, running shootouts and engine tournaments from the position in question until he thinks he’s found the best move then he plays it.  What if it turns out it isn’t the best move and his judgment was wrong?  He loses just like he would in any OTB game.
      Is playing chess this way enjoyable?  Depends on the individual.  If it isn’t, play on sites that disallow engines. Of course if you’re playing on a site where they are prohibited and you run into an engine user then you have a right to complain.  Otherwise keep your cybermouth shut. Thank you.

Friday, July 13, 2012

Odd Openings

       There exist a lot of openings that you never see in master practice, but not all of them are unsound; in some cases they just aren’t popular while in other cases they may be, if not positionally suspect, just not dynamic enough to generate any interest.  I remember GM Robert Byrne writing an article where he discussed what he called, if memory serves, twilight openings.  He gave the Budapest Gambit as one example stating that it’s playable even if rarely seen.  In a recent correspondence game I met a 2400+ opponent who played an unbooked opening as white against me.  Engines rely on opening books because so far with their books turned off, none of them have succeeded in discovering a “new” opening that GM’s consider worthwhile.
       In the game in question, I am assuming my opponent wanted to get me out of the book and at the same time, get into a position where it’s likely his positional judgment will outweigh mine and/or an engine. The game opened:

1.e4 e5 2.Qf3 Nc6
A game Dimitrov,P (2404)-Mazi,L (2374) Zadar 2008 continued 2...Nf6 3.Bc4 d6 4.h3 c6 5.d3 Be6 6.Bb3 Nbd7 7.c3 g6 8.Ne2 Bg7 9.0–0 0–0 and what can you say?  The position is fully equal.
3.c3
Also good is 3.Bc4 Nf6 4.Ne2 Bc5 and now black can play 4...d6 5.Nbc3 Bg4 6.Qg3 Qd7 7.d3 h6 8.0–o as in Varavin,V (2399)-Tolstikh,N (2425) Alushta 2004 or, for that matter, any number of engine recommendations all of which look OK for black.
3...Bc5 4.Ne2 Nf6 5.d3 d5
And now Black seems to have full equality, if not slightly the better game.

       That got me to thinking maybe I ought to try something different in one of my own games.  So in the following game I decided to forego my usual standard solid, mainline stuff and play something crazy, but not totally unsound.

1.d4 d5 2.Bg5 Qd6
Entering uncharted territory.  This move looks like an old time engine move from days gone by when they didn’t have much of a book.  Obviously it violates opening principles and isn’t something you’d want to play against a GM, but the move is not totally new.
3.e3 Qb6
This really takes us out of the books! Black played it safe in the game Urbina,C-Elflow,K Mallorca 2004 continued 4.Bd3 g6 5.Nf3 Bg7 6.0–0 0–0 7.Nc3 Nc6 8.Qe2 Bg4 9.Qe1 Bxf3 10.gxf3 e5 11.Nb5 Qe7 12.e4 dxe4 13.Bxe4 Nxd4 14.Nxd4 exd4 15.Rd1 Rfd8 16.Bxb7 Qxe1 17.Rfxe1 Rab8 18.Bc6 Rxb2 19.Re7 Rxc2 20.Rxc7 Rd6 21.Rc8+ Bf8 22.Bh6 Nd7 23.Bb7 Rxc8 24.Bxc8 Bxh6 0–1 Urbina,C-Elflow,K Mallorca 2004.

While Ivanova,D-Vladimirova,D, Ruse 20073...Bf5 4.Bd3 Qg6 5.Nf3 h6 6.Bxf5 Qxf5 7.Bf4 and it’s obvious White has a comfortable game. 
4.Nf3 …
There is lots of room for analysis at this point. The engines prefer 4.Nc3 when 4...Qxb2? 5.Nxd5 loses for black.
4...Qxb2?!
There wasn’t much point to playing 3…Qb3 if this isn’t the followup! This is safe now.  By safe I mean there is no immediate disaster as a result of the move, but after a likely continuation of:
5.Nbd2 Nf6 6.Rb1 Qc3 7.Rb3 Qa5 8.c4 c6

It should be pretty clear that black’s position is not one you would find many player’s willing to accept over the board, but in correspondence play it might be defensible.

In seems that in these two examples there isn’t any clear refutation and these lines might be worth looking into with the idea of generating some engine analysis and creating your own variations.  You probably won’t want to play them against Anand the next time you meet him though.