Harry Nelson
Pillsbury (December 5, 1872 – June 17, 1906) at the
age 22 won one of the strongest tournaments of the time, Hastings 1895, but illness
and early death prevented him from challenging for the world championship. His poor mental and physical health prevented him
from realizing his full potential and he succumbed in a Philadelphia hospital
in 1906. Pillsbury is buried in Laurel
Hill Cemetery in Reading, Massachusetts.
Many explanations
have been offered for Pillsbury's decline. The general consensus for a long
time was that he caught syphilis from a prostitute while playing in St.
Petersburg 1895 and that caused his poor performance in the second half of the
tournament. Others have suggested it was not the effects of the disease but
that he received the diagnosis of the
disease on the day of his game with Lasker and the news had psychological
effects that prevented his giving his best performance.
These explanations
do not seem to make sense because if Pillsbury was infected with syphilis while
playing in the St. Petersburg tournament it is highly unlikely he would have
suffered any serious symptoms until sometime afterwards. The symptoms of syphilis may take up to 3 months to appear after initial
infection. So it doesn’t seem
possible that he would have been diagnosed as having the disease immediately
after catching it and no blood test for syphilis existed in those days.
There is no question
that Pillsbury was ill during the second half of the tournament because many of
his games were postponed. An article from the Brooklyn Eagle in January 1896 said
that Pillsbury was suffering from influenza that had afflicted him during the
second half of the tournament. Interestingly, one of the symptoms of
second-stage syphilis is similar to severe flu. Thus it is possible Pillsbury
caught syphilis some time earlier and the symptoms were manifested during the
tournament. On the other hand, it is quite possible that he did have the flu. Obviously if Pillsbury was suffering from second stage during
the tournament it would mean he contracted it some time before.
In A Catalog of USA Chess Personalia
by Jeremy Gaige (Worcester, 1980) the following comments about Pillsbury
appeared:
“...
it should be noted that his death certificate said he died of “general
paresis”, i.e. syphilis. I
have found many other indications in Philadelphia that this was in fact the
case, e.g. the scrapbooks of Walter Penn Shipley contained a typewritten
obituary (presumably by Shipley himself) that said Pillsbury died of general
paresis.”
According to the PubMed
Health website, general paresis is a
problem with mental function due to damage to the brain from untreated
syphilis. This damage can cause abnormal mental function including hallucinations and delusions, brief sharp pains, decreased
mental function, eye changes and abnormal pupil response, mood changes, overactive
reflexes, personality and speech changes.
General paresis usually begins about 15 - 20 years after the syphilis
infection. Risks include syphilis infection and infection with other sexually
transmitted diseases, such as gonorrhea which may hide symptoms of syphilis
infection.
W.D. Rubinstein wrote to chess historian
Jeremy Gaige on27 October 1982:
“I have no documentation on where he
(Pillsbury) contracted syphilis. Interestingly, Friends Asylum still has the
day-by-day log and medical records of Pillsbury, but strictly forbids any
inspection of same. Tantalizingly, a hospital official read me a few innocuous
sentences from the records, but that is all. I did have two indirect accounts
that he did in fact contract the disease in St Petersburg (from Bill Ruth
1886-1975 and J. Edmund Peckover 1896-1982). Peckover said he was told that
version by A.B. Hodges, who said he was told that by Pillsbury himself.”
The July 1906 edition of the British Chess Magazine gave Pillsbury’s obituary:
“On his return to Philadelphia he was
examined by the best medical experts, one of whom, Dr. Charles K. Mills, a
noted specialist of great repute in the United States, expressed the opinion
that Mr. Pillsbury’s affliction was not caused by his chessplaying, and this
testimony was supported by Dr. Chase, also an expert on the subject of paresis.
The probability is that the real cause of the breakdown was irregularity in
time of eating and sleeping, and the neglect of out-door exercise, together
with excessive smoking.”
In America's Chess Heritage Walter Korn
documents numerous symptoms that would indicate Pillsbury actually was
suffering from aneurysm, which would have caused erratic, sometimes suicidal
behavior.
Many people infected
with syphilis do not have any symptoms for years and the latent (hidden) stage begins
when the primary and secondary symptoms disappear. Without treatment, the
infected person will continue to have syphilis even though there are no signs
or symptoms and this latent stage can last for years. The late stages of
syphilis appear 10–20 years after infection was first acquired. In the late
stages the disease may subsequently damage the internal organs, including the
brain, nerves, eyes, heart, blood vessels, liver, bones, and joints. Signs and
symptoms of the late stage of syphilis include difficulty coordinating muscle
movements, paralysis, numbness, gradual blindness, and dementia. This damage
may be serious enough to cause death.
So, because syphilis is a disease that does
not show up immediately but can take years to develop, how could Pillsbury pinpoint
St. Petersburg 1895 as the place where he contracted it? As mentioned earlier, according to PubMed
Health, if general paresis shows up 15–20 years after
syphilis infection then Pillsbury would have contracted syphilis at the unlikely
age of around seven. Thought: is it
possible he was infected with syphilis at birth, the disease possibly having
been transmitted through his mother? I suppose it’s also conceivable that he
had contacted the disease much earlier in his teen years.
Pillsbury was also known for his blindfold play
and mental feats of memorization. Before he died psychologists were studying
Pillsbury’s brain and his mental powers. After he died, his brain was actually
studied.
In 1906, Emmanual Lasker wrote the following
about Pillsbury’s brain and death in the New York Times:
“Pillsbury, the American chess champion, died
last Sunday (June 17, 1906). The cause of his premature departure was a stroke
of apoplexy. The mechanism of his brain had become defective. With the examples
of Morphy and Steinitz in their minds, many writers have commented on the tendency
of famous chess players to insanity. A general belief has consequently been
engendered that chess playing, or any very intensive purely mental occupation
disorganizes the intellect. But this belief is entirely unfounded. It is in the
highest degree mischievous.
Physiologically it is clear why the man who
cares most for the development of his physique and the senses should suffer. He
puts a load on the heart that the brain is not allowed to share. Thus both
organs deteriorate the one from overexertion, the other one from lack of use.
The man whose critical faculty is developed
will never strain any more of his organs beyond the power of endurance. The
uncritical mind, in the quest for pleasure, often oversteps this limit.
Happiness is entirely a state of mind.
Chess has an important function to fulfill.
Opportunities for enjoying works of art or for studying scientific books are
afforded in plenty. But the spirit of fight – calling into being so many
faculties of man – in modern society rarely finds occasion for manifestation
and practice. The ancient game of chess fills out this gap. While the two
armies of 16 pieces each contend with each other in mimic warfare according to
acknowledged rules, the brain of the player is in constant agitation. Here he
must foresee the result of a hostile maneuver, analyzing its outcome sharply to
find out whether it is time for defense or whether he should make his opponent
press him still harder before he parries.
Chess requires courage thus to expose one’s
self to the certainty of danger, yet his strategic convictions tell him that
the offered sacrifice is unsound, that if he only finds the right replies he
should win. But he anxiously asks himself whether he is not mistaken. His moral
courage struggles in him. The struggle on the board has a counterpoint in the
soul of the man.
A long series of such experiences must
develop in the chess player certain portions of his mind that, unless
circumstances are very favorable, are usually dwarfed. A belief in the logic of
events, not alone in the chessboard, must take hold of him.
For these and many other reasons it cannot be
doubted that the brain considerably gains in force by the practice of chess
play. And therefore, according to our thesis, we must conclude that in modern
society the ideal man would be a chess player.”
A quaint argument but Morphy didn’t go insane
on account of chess and during the last 30 years of his life he never played
and did not show any signs of insanity until about 10 years before he died. Steinitz was mildly insane in spite of chess
and Rubenstein showed signs of mental illness early in his career.
Pillsbury allowed himself to be
exploited. He gave blindfold
performances where the promoters insisted he play a number of games that was at
the very limit of his capacity while at the same time he did memory tricks, played
checkers and whist. At the same time he
also smoked heavily and drank whisky.
These sessions were very exhausting and friends warned him of the danger
to his health, but he never listened.
In the early part of the twentieth century,
Dr. Elmer Southard, Professor of Psychology at Harvard University, studied
Pillsbury’s brain in an attempt to decide whether a genius for chess tends to
deteriorate the mind. He found no difference between a chess player’s brain and
anyone else’s. No surprise there.