Pre-arranged results are nothing new. The fifth American Chess Congress (a double round event) was held in New York on January 6–26, 1880, and won by George H, Mackenzie after he beat James Grundy in a tiebreak match, 2–0.
The fight for first place turned out to be a close race and in the final round James Grundy was paired against Preston Ware. According to Ware he was walking down the street with Grundy who remarked to Ware that he was poor and really needed the second place prize money ($300, or over $9,000 in today’s currency).
Grundy added that when Ware beat him in their first game it had knocked him out of the running for first place ($550, or a little over $15,000 today). He also added that both Charles Mohle and Max Judd were well off. So, if Ware were to take it easy on Grundy it would assure him second prize and earn Ware $20 in bribe money...a little over $500 today).
The two agreed to play very slowly and to move back and forth to prolong the game until the other games were finished. The game was adjourned and was to be resumed later that evening after a meal break. At the meal Grundy told him that he (Grundy, who had plenty of time on his clock) would arrive late and Ware should go ahead and start his clock.
Then, instead of arriving late, Grundy arrived on time and when they began playing, Ware started shifting piece as per their agreement, but then he realized that Grundy was making a desperate effort to win, which he finally did and as a result he managed to tie for first.
The tournament book summed up the case by stating that Ware’s allegation, which implicated himself as an accomplice in the crime “in the undignified transaction” were opposed by a firm denial on Grundy’s part.
The tournament book concluded that the case became a question of veracity between two individuals, one of whom freely admitted his guilt while the other pronounced the story as a complete fabrication. In the absence of any corroborative testimony the tournament committee could not impose any penalty upon either player.
My guess is that Ware didn’t get his $20 either.
In any case, even though the game was riddled with mistakes it was quire interesting. Take a look...
Preston Ware–James Grundy0–1D005th American Congress, New YorkManhattan, New York USA26.01.1880Stockfish 16
QP Opening 1.d4 d5 2.g5 c6 3.e3 a6 4.h3 f6 5.c3 The opening is
similar to an irregular Torre Attack f5 6.d3 g6 7.a3 d7 8.f3 e4 9.f4 9.xe4 xe4 10.xe4 dxe4 11.d2 f5 White has not accomplished much
owing to the exchange of minor pieces. 9...f6 This is a bist risky. Simply
9...Nxc3 was good. 10.xe4 dxe4 Taking with the B was better. 11.d2 f5
Unlike in the previous note this is now quite bad because white has sufficient
minor pieces to actually work uip an attack against black's weakened K-side. 11...e6 12.dxe4 0-0-0 13.e2 e5 Black is a P down, but at least he has
some play. 12.d5 d8 13.c4 f7 14.e2 h6 15.e5 xe5 16.xe5 f7 17.d1 c6 18.dxc6 18.f3 This attacks the weakened P-chain and keeps the
advantage. cxd5 19.fxe4 fxe4 20.0-0 e6 21.xe4 with an excellent position.
18...xc6 19.0-0 Oddly enough, as bad as black's position looks he
actually has sufficient play that the position can be considered equal. g8 19...c4 leads to interesting play after 20.h5+ g6 21.h4 xf1 21...g8 22.fe1 g5 23.h5+ f7 24.e2 c8 22.xh8 c4 20.d2 Now come
maneuvering to kill time as per their agreement. e6 21.e2 c5 22.d2 c6 23.e2 e7 24.d2 c5 25.g3 g5 26.fd1 White's position is the more
promising. Black should bow offer to exchange Rs with 26...Rd8 e5 This is
too loosening especially with his K in the center. 27.d5 f4 Grundy clearly
has some ideas about attacking...the correct decision because white stands
very well. 28.b4 Not the best; it loses most of his advantage. 28.exf4 exf4 29.xe4 xd5 29...fxg3 results in disater. 30.f6+ f8 31.d7+ 30.xd5 c6 31.h2 g6 32.e2 f8 33.d7 White is much better. 28...c6± 29.h2 d8 30.c4 g6 31.c5 31.exf4 is not as good because complications
arise and black gets good play after gxf4 32.c5 e3 33.fxe3 e4 34.xe7 xd2 35.h5+ xe7 36.xd2 g5 31...h5 This results in white gaining what
should have been a decisive advantage. 31...f7 keeps white's advantage to
a level had is far from decisive. 32.xe7 xe7 33.d6 xd6 34.xd6 e8 35.xh6 d7 36.d6 f5 32.xe7 xe7 33.d6 xd6 34.xd6 c8 35.b2 f5 36.d2 A passive move that allows black to equalize. 36.b5 keeps up the
pressure. axb5 37.xb5 c8 38.b3 f7 39.c3 leaves black struggling. 36...e8 36...f7 was much better. For example... 37.b6 d7 37...b8 38.d6+ 38.xd7+ xd7 39.xb7+ 37.c3 37.d5 was the winner. f8 38.xb7 g4 39.xa6 The threat is obviously Rg6+ Black has no good move. 37...c6 38.d2 g4 39.exf4 White's passive play has allowed black to
equalize, but this move, opening up hus K's position, is a serious mistake. 39.
b6 was good. gxh3 Black counters his opponent's last move by missing the
winning line. 39...e3 40.d1 40.fxe3 gxh3 41.g3 b1+ 42.d1 e4 43.f2 g2+ 44.e1 xh2 and wins. 40...gxh3 41.g3 g4 42.d3 xd1+ 43.xd1 exf4 44.h4+ f7 45.g3 exf2+ 46.xf2 h2 wins 40.g3 exf4 41.h4+ f7
41...f8 and black has nothing to worry. 42.d4 42.f6+
would be a serious mistake! xf6 43.xf6 xg2+ 44.h1 e3 45.d8+ f7 46.c7+ g6 47.f3 xf3 48.xf4 c6 49.b8 d2+ 50.g1 h2+ 51.xh2 d1# 42...xg2+ 43.h1 e3 44.f6+ xf6 45.xf6+ The position of white's Q and B make
all the difference. Compare this position to the one after white wins the Q in
the sub-variation (43.Bxf6). g8 46.e6+ draws 46.d8+ h7 47.d3+ h6 48.d6+ g6+ 46...h7 47.f5+ g8 47...g6+ 48.h2 white wins 48.e6+ etc. 42.g3 This is a horrible move! 42.a2+ was the
only winning move. f8 43.d8+ e8 44.xe8+ xe8 45.xg8+ d7 46.d8+ e6 47.gxh3 g6+ 48.h2 White has a won ending. 42...e3 This looks good,
but it misses the win. 42...fxg3 43.fxg3 g6 44.xg6 xg6 45.f2+ g7
with a won ending. 43.a2+ g7 44.fxe3 A gross blunder. 44.f6+ forces black to surrender his Q, but he gets sufficient compensation for
it. xf6 44...f8 45.d8+ e8 46.xe8+ xe8 47.xg8+ d7 48.d8+
wins...just one example... c6 49.b6+ d5 49...d7 50.d6+ mste next
move. 50.d6+ c4 51.fxe3 b1+ 51...fxe3 52.f4+ 52.h2 fxg3+ 53.xh3 f1+ 54.xg3 and wins. 45.xf6 xf6 46.xg8 exf2+ 47.xf2 44...fxg3 45.xg3 h7 45...h4 was even better. 46.f4 h7+ 46.h6+ g7 47.e6 xe6 48.xe6 f7 49.xc6 bxc6 The ending is won for black and
he plays the remainder of the game in a decent fashion. 50.h2 g6 51.e4 g5 52.xh3 f8 53.a4 f3 54.g2 g4 55.d6 b3 56.b5 axb5 57.axb5 xb5 58.e5 b2+ 59.h1 e2 60.g1 h4 61.f1 f3 62.g1 h3 63.h1 g4 64.g1 h2+
Ware resigned 64...h2+ 65.f1 b2 mate next move. 0–1