The city I live in has a nice, big main library with several branches and occasionally I visit them. Naturally the first thing I do is look to see what chess books they have. I still can’t figure it out...sometimes they have a Reinfeld book or two, but other times they have several decent books. Say, for example, The Art of Chess Analysis by Jan Timman. Why they have different books every visit is a mystery.
The other day I discovered The Chinese School of Chess by Liu Wenzhe lurking in the games sections. It was published in 2002 and you can buy it for $30 if you’re into spending a lot of money on chess books. I used to, but fortunately kicked the habit a long time ago. But, it’s free to check books out at the library, so I brought it home and must say I enjoyed it.
Googling the author revealed that the late Liu Wenzhe (October 7, 1940 – September 20, 2011) was an International Master and one of China's top chess trainers. Originally a XiangQi (Chinese chess) player, Wenzhe was one of the first to take a serious interest in "Western" chess which he began playing and studying in the late 1950s.
According to Chessmetrics his rating was in the 2300s until 1989 when he was inactive. He apparently resumed play in 2000, but by then he was 59 years old and his rating slipped to the 2100s.
He was the first Chinese player to defeat a GM (Nikolai Krogius in 1965) and the first to be awarded the title of International Master. He is considered a pioneer of chess in China and a founding father of the Chinese School of Chess.
He won the Chinese Chess Championship in 1980 and 1982.
Two years after the end of the Cultural Revolution and Mao Zedong's death and the fall of the Gang of Four in 1976, China competed in their first Olympiad in Buenos Aires. It was there that Liu Wenzhe played his best known game when he crushed Dutch GM Jan Hein Donner in twenty moves. The game, with notes based on Liu Wenzhe’s annotations, is given below and it’s a lot of fun to play over.
Like The Soviet School of Chess by Kotov and Yudovich, the book has its share of propaganda telling readers what a swell system of government Communism is as proven by the large number of good chess players it produced. I suppose saying that was required if you wanted to avoid disappearing into the abyss.
Actually I think it was a function of numbers.
When I played in my first junior tournament at the age of 15 or 16, I was one of the youngest players out of 20 or 25 participants. Nowadays you can’t visit a tournament without stepping on a five year old. There was one Hispanic and one girl playing. Then came the Fischer Boom and all of a sudden minority players started showing up. At first they weren’t very good, but as more and more started playing that changed.
Here in the US we had very few registered players and a thimble full of Masters. In the Soviet Union they had millions of players and a boat load of Masters. I suspect the same thing happened in China. With more than one billion Chinese it should be no surprise that with the help of government supported programs a lot of strong players will be discovered and encouraged.
The book supposedly reveals the unique approach, training methods and secrets of his Chinese School of Chess based on "The Art of Thinking." According to the introduction, when Botvinnik published his Soviet School of Chess nobody dared challenged the theories postulated by the Soviet School until Liu Wenzhe came along.
The book is a summary of his training methods and the emphasis is on positional play. Much of his analysis is long...very long...which means it’s most likely filled with mistakes. Think long, think wrong!
If you’re like me, you’re dying to know what the Chinese method for success is. There isn’t any. Well, not exactly. He does a lot of yammering about the Chinese players’ approach to the middlegame, their flexible thinking, strategic skills, etc. But so did Kotov and Yudovich in their Soviet School of Chess.
In the Road To Chess Mastery, GM Alex Yermolinsky let the cat out of the bag about the Soviet School. He saw plenty of bad teaching in the Soviet Union. He also wrote, “There were no secret methods of teaching...In my 30 years of tournament experience I have seen a lot of bad players and most of them lived in the Soviet Union.” He also added that his teacher, the celebrated Vladimir Zak, while he had a good eye for talent, couldn’t help players by the time they reached 1800!
So why was Liu Wenzhe so successful in his training of Xie Jun for her 1991 World Championship match against Maia Chiburdanidze? Simple. For 6 months she was totally immersed in chess. Every day she followed a strict regimen that included eight hours of chess training and even breaks, meal times and bedtimes (10:15pm) were regulated. No diversions, no time with friends, entertainment or movies.
Nothing but studying chess!
All in all, even though he doesn’t reveal any secret plans that will enable those of us who are rating challenged to climb the ladder of success, the book, especially the annotations, was an interesting read.
[Event "Olympiad"]
[Site "Buenos Aires "]
[Date "1978.??.??"]
[Round "?"]
[White "Liu Wenzhe"]
[Black "J.H. Donner"]
[Result "1-0"]
[WhiteELO "?"]
[BlackELO "?"]
%Created by Caissa's Web PGN Editor
{Modern Defence} 1. e4 d6 2. d4 Nf6 {When auto-annotating this with the Fritz
12 GUI, it called this opening the Pirc Defense, but according to the
Wikipedia article that is not correct. I says the Modern Defense (aka the
Robatsch Defense) is closely related to the Pirc, the primary difference being
that in the Modern, black delays developing his N to f6.} 3. Nc3 g6 4. Be2
Bg7 {White has a gaggle of moves to chose from, 11 according to the Fritz 12
opening book, the most popular being 5.Nf3.} 5. g4 {This is the 4th most
popular and its results are actually pretty good. Wenzhe says it is a
provocative move, but points out such moves can be dangerous if met
incorrectly.} 5... h6 {Wenzhe wrote, What awes me is the antidote to this
provocation 5..d5! moving a pawn twice in the opening, goes against opening
principles -is hard to find if your mind is locked on playing properly.
Donner spent half an hour on this move which pleased his Wenzhe because it
meant his unexpected move had already put Donner at a psychological
disadvantage. On the other hand, Wenzhe hadn't anticipated such a
straightforward defense. The move was questioned by some, but Wenzhe thought
it was still an effective choice.} 6. h3 {Wenzhe originally intended 6.h4 but
couldn't see how to continue after that. He felt his Q and B would then be
tied to the defense of his g-Pawn and that would spell trouble when black
strikes in the center. Thus, he felt his last move was wasted. He decided
his best plan was to stabilize the center in oreder to be able to launch a
K-side attack.} 6... c5 7. d5 O-O {Donner had played his last two moves
quickly and Wenzhe guessed that when Donner castled it meant he was very
pleased with his 5th move. Donner apparently believed if that white did not
dare play h2-h4 then white had been forced to give up plans of a K-side
attack. Wenzhe called it a psychological error. Better plans were either
7...a6 with play on the Q-side or attacking white's center with 7...e6.} 8.
h4 {A dogmatic theorist might call this move a loss of a tempo. However,
chess is not simply mathematical. The point is that black has made
concessions on the K-side in terms of both space and time. When combined with
premature castling, h7-h6 turns out to be a bad move which wasted time and
allow white to open the h-file. (Wenzhe) He also added that when the K is
the target of a mating attack, theory is meaningless. Purdy made the same
point decades ago when he wrote that when a SOUND tactic is available
positional considerations can be ignored.} 8... e6 9. g5 {Now blac's best move
is 9...Nh7 but even then white has the upper hand.} 9... hxg5 10. hxg5 Ne8
11. Qd3 {After this move Wenzhe was sure he was going to win. That opinion
was based on his attacking skills. He is quite correct. Stockfish alread
gives white a score of almost 2.5 Ps which is a winning advantage for a
skilled player.} 11... exd5 {All this move does is allow white to add fuel to
the fire by placing a N on d5. There isn't much to do except try to defend
with 11...Nc7.} 12. Nxd5 Nc6 13. Qg3 {Black can try 13... f5, but after
14.gxf6 Nxf6 15.Qxg6 his position is hopeless.} 13... Be6 {After this white
has a mate in 11 moves with either 14.Qh4 or 14.Qh2.} 14. Qh4 {Wenzhe wrote
that after this he thought about continuing the attack with Bc4, but then the
idea of a Q-sac dawned on him. At the same time he was very nervous about
botching it!} 14... f5 {Black can only delay, but not prevent mate. If white
hadn't realized the idea of a Q-sac and played the originally intended 15.Bc4
then 15...b5 16.Nf6 Kf7 17.Bxe6+ Kxe6 18.exf5+ he would have a very dangerous,
even winning, attack but at least black can play on.} 15. Qh7+ Kf7 {According
to Wenzhe, Donner looked optimistic in view of his threat of 16...Rh8.
Actually I'm not sure I believe that. Donner was a strong GM and I am
positive he realized that even after the prosaic 16.Nf4 (attacking the g-Pawn)
Ne7 (Defending it) 17.Bh5 white has a winning attack. Wenzhe added that
Donner didn't seem too perturbed by the Q-sac and played quickly, probably
hoping Wenzhe would misplay the attack. Even when you're dead lost it's not a
good idea to act like you socks are on fire.} 16. Qxg6+ Kxg6 17. Bh5+ Kh7 18.
Bf7+ Bh6 {White still has a chance to booger up his attack and lose! His next
move is the only one that wins. Tempting is 19.Rxh6+ but after 19...Kg7 20.
Bxe6 fxe4 white's attack is over and he is left with a material deficit of two
Bs against the Q} 19. g6+ Kg7 20. Bxh6+ {It' mate in two: 20...Kh8 21.Bxf8+
and mate next move.} 1-0