My chess book collection consists mostly of old books. i.e. they are in descriptive notation and, of course, are pre-engine. The question is, can they be trusted? The answer is, I suppose, it depends. In the case of opening books, the ideas may not have changed, but engines will sometimes alter the evaluation of individual moves.
In practice though I don’t think it matters much. Below the Master level (or perhaps even the VERY strong Master level) the players don’t follow published analysis very far anyway...sometimes only 5-6 moves.
Also, for non-Masters even a huge opening plus can be frittered away.
Also, some popular openings of today were unknown way back when and many once popular openings are now obsolete. Consequently, in the old books comments on the openings must generally be looked at with a jaundiced eye.
Many books on middlegame strategy hold up better and are still useful. Tactics are another matter because they can be iffy. Often those old books were cranked out out without a lot of analytic effort and they didn’t have the benefit of an all-seeing engine. Also, in may cases the games were annotated based on the result. Everything the winner did was praised and everything the loser did was criticized.
 |
Spielmann |
However, for non-Masters and those of us for whom the improvement ship has sailed, the games in those old books are a source of enjoyment.
The following game is one such. It was played in 1934 in a tournament in Sopron, a city in Hungary on the Austrian border. The tournament itself has been long forgotten and few games survive. The event was won by Rudolf Spielmann and Erno Gereben finished second. The other players were Pal Rethy, I. Csath, Antonio Sacconi, Arpad Vajda, Laszlo Szabo, Immo Fuss, Kornel Havasi and Ernst Gruenfeld, but I was unable to locate the final standings.
The game appears in Spielmann’s book, The Art of Sacrifice in Chess. Rudolf Spielmann (1883-1942, 59 years old) was born in Vienna, Austria. His chess persona was the exact opposite of his personality away from the board. He loved complex positions and tactics.
Being Jewish, he fled Nazi Germany and in 1939 went to Sweden. His death is something of a mystery. According to his close relatives he locked himself in his room and was later found starved to death.  |
Gereben |
Another version says that he suffered from am illness similar to Parkinson's disease which rapidly became worse at the end of his life. Parkinson’s disease is a disorder of the central nervous system that affects movement. It often starts with a tremor in one hand. Other symptoms are slow movement, stiffness, and loss of balance. There are, however, several other conditions that can mimic Parkinson’s.
Another source stated that he was admitted to the hospital and he died there. The source adds that the official cause of death was high blood pressure and a condition in which the heart muscle becomes fibrous.
His opponent was Erno Gereben (1908-1988), a Hungarian-Swiss Master whose career extended from the mid-1920s to the late 1970s. He was born in Sopron, where this tournament was played. Due to the Hungarian revolution in 1956, Gereben emigrated to Switzerland. He was awarded the IM title in 1950.
As for the game itself, like the game in the preceding post, it represents the evils of having not castled in an open position. Spielmann’s sacrifice lead to an attack against the exposed King whose defending pieces were largely undeveloped and somewhat scattered left him with excellent attacking chances. As is often the case, the defender was not up to the task of defending which is often harder than attacking. As for Spielmann’s notes in the book, let’s just say he didn’t have Stockfish and leave it at that.
Shootouts are mentioned in the analysis. As a reminder, this is a feature in the Fritz program in which an engine play out the rest of the game. It’s useful to test different engines by letting them play out a tactical, strategic or endgame position at different depths, but it’s also useful for analysis purposes to see what the potential outcome might be.
A game that I liked (Fritz 17)
1.d4 f6 2.c4 g6 3.c3 d5 4.e3 g7 5.f3 0-0 6.d2 c6 7.b3 b6 8.cxd5 cxd5 9.c1 b7 10.e5 fd7 11.xd7 11.f4 xe5 12.fxe5 f6 13.exf6 xf6 14.b5 c6 15.xd5+ xd5 16.xd5 11...xd7 12.f4 e5 13.fxe5 xe5 14.dxe5 d4 15.d1 15.exd4 xd4 16.e2 xe5 17.c3 15...xe5 16.e4 xe4 17.f2 d5 18.h3 18.c4 xg2 19.g1 b7 20.d1 f6 21.g4 f3+ 22.e2 xg4 23.xg4 xh2 24.h3 e5 25.d3 e6 26.c4 f5 27.h4 xh3 28.xh3 18...e7 18...xa2 19.d3 c8 20.0-0 xc1 21.xc1 19.e2 d3 20.xd3 fe8 21.f1 21.0-0 d4+ 22.h1 xe2 21.e3 h4+ 22.g3 xg3+ 23.xg3 xg3+ 24.hxg3 xh1 25.f2 21...xb2 21...ad8 22.e3 b7 23.xe5 xg2+ 24.g1 xh1 25.f3 xf3 26.xf3 xf3 27.xf3 22.e1 f6+ 23.f2 d4 24.g3 e4 24...xe2 25.xe2 xf2 26.f4 xf4 27.xf4 xe1 28.xe1 24...e5 25.c3 25.c1 xf2 26.xf2 f5 25...xc3 26.xc3 ae8 27.c2 b5 28.h4 c4 29.g4 xe2 30.xe2 xe2 25.h4 25.c1 ae8 26.f3 4e7 27.h4 e3 28.xe3 xe3 29.g4 b2 30.xe3 xc1+ 31.d1 xf3 32.xf3 d8 33.f2 25...ae8 26.b5 xe1+ 27.xe1 e3 27...xe1+ 28.xe1 xf2+ 29.xf2 a1+ 30.d2 xh1 28.g5 xe1+! 29.xe1 xf2+ 30.d1 xg2 31.e1 f3+ 32.e2 c3 33.xf3 xf3+ 34.c2 xe1 35.d8+ g7 0–1