...or
good quick thinking?
A few years ago I posted about this
incident in the forum at Chessworld and it created quite a stir. Some thought it was amusing while others
thought it was despicable. I feel bad
about it but please remember every saint was a sinner in his youth.
It was in the early 1970’s and I entered a
small tournament with a time limit of 30/30. I was rated about 1700 at the time and was the
highest rated player there by about 300 points so I was going to cruise to the
$50 first prize.
My first round opponent was rated
around 1100 so it was going to be an easy win. I was sitting there staring at
my fingernails when a friend walked by, glanced at the position, snickered
& walked away. I looked down and realized to my horror my opponent had a
mate in one.
He
kept thinking and I was fervently hoping he wouldn’t see the mate. After what
seemed like an eternity he reached out and grabbed his Q and played the move
that mated me. BUT…he didn’t say anything and I realized HE didn’t realize I
was mated. So, I blitzed out a move offering to exchange Queens; he thought a few
seconds and made the trade. We continued the game and I won. When he wanted to
do a PM I refused and the poor guy never knew what happened.
Not ethical, but it poses an interesting
question. I lost the game theoretically, but as far as tournament rules are
concerned if the win was not claimed by my opponent or the tournament director,
then legally I don't know if I lost. If you overstep the time limit, it is the
responsibility of your opponent to claim the win on time. Likewise, my opponent
should have claimed a win by mate, but he did not.
Fate has a way of evening things out
though. On the way home I stopped and
used the prize money to help pay for something I had always wanted…an
aquarium. It cost me about $100. I
bought a tank, sand, rocks, plants and, of course, fish and then rushed home
and set everything up.
A few days later for some reason all the
fish died, so I had to replace them. It
wasn’t long after that the tank got some kind of algae infestation and all the
fish died. I cleaned the tank out and
replaced the fish again. It wasn’t long
after that that another algae infestation killed every last one of them. After that I gave up. My $50 prize money was gone several times
over.